Two Thirds Done

Thoughts and experiences of an eighty one year old Wild Duck.

Avram Miller by the sea
EN | IT

587 posts since 2006

Category: World Situation

  • The Greening of Gaza: Hummus not Hamas

     

    As they say, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. That is exactly what is happening in Gaza now.

    Israel has no choice, but to defend itself
    Given the current situation that confronts Israel with Hamas shooting thousands of missiles, building tens of massive tunnels stocked with arms, stealing Israeli Army uniforms with the objective in imitating Israeli soldiers and killing and capturing civilians, Israel has no real option but to take action against Hamas. But the predictable results of this are that civilians are being killed and injured, no matter how much care Israel takes to prevent that, and I do believe that they take a great deal of care to warn civilians in targeted areas before they strike. Civilian deaths are relatively low given the actions that Israel is taking.

     

    Photoshop, a weapon of war
    There is also a PR war in which Israel is not doing very well. Hamas has a strategy to maximize the death of civilians and publicize this. I was shocked when a dear Palestinian friend posted a photo on Facebook of about ten dead children all lined up neatly. I am sure that these children were not all killed in the same place or at the same time, but placed together for a photo-op. Or perhaps its was done by Photoshop one of the surprising weapons in this war. The BBC recently wrote about this kind of thing.

     

    The more things change, the more they stay the same

    The results of this current conflict are clear. There will be a ceasefire. Israel does not have the desire to reoccupy Gaza, which would be required to eliminate or at least tame Gaza. Hamas will be strengthened in the eyes of the people living in Gaza for standing up to Israel. Countries like Qatar will provide Hamas with financial assistance much of which will go into the pockets of the Hamas leadership to add to the billions they have already stolen. But they will use some of this money to buy even more effective weapons probably from Iran and Russia. Israel will spend money to improve its anti-missile capabilities. There will be quiet for a few years. Israelis can relax once again in the cafe’s of Tel Aviv while Pro-Palestinian supporters can go back to whatever they were doing before to make the world a better place, which I don’t think was much. The world’s attention will move to Iraq and Syria where Arabs to do other Arabs the things that Hamas would like to do to Israelis.

     

    Sixty-Six Years of Blaming the Jews and sucking at the tit of the UN
    Children in Gaza will grow up being thought to hate and to blame their problem on the Jews. The population of Gaza will continue to grow because there is nothing much to do there, but have children and exist on money from the UN.

    The generations of Palestinian refugees in living in Arab countries will still not get citizenship in the countries where they were born, and even their parents and grandparents were born. The Palestinian Authority in the West Bank under the leadership of Abbas, will do what it can to maintain the status quo while looking like it wants an independent country. Without Israel’s support, the PA knows that Hamas will do to them what they would like to do to Israel.

     

    What me worry?
    Israelis will go back to thinking that Israel is somehow not in the middle east but located in Southern California. Anti-Semitism in Europe and, in particular France, will cause continued emigration to Israel. What has just happened with Hamas sending missiles into all of Israel has guaranteed that there will not be a Palestinian nation. The issue with security in Israel, given how close the West Bank is to the major population centers of Israel and its only Airport, means that Israel will not take its army out of the West Bank. And as long as Israel occupies the West Bank, they will build more settlements, more Israeli highways, and building more walls to slice and dice the West Bank.

    Writing this post, I am feeling very sad and almost want to cry. It does not have to be this way.

     
    What and why is Gaza?
    The town of Gaza has been around for more than 4,000 years. Prior to 1948, it was a small fishing village but one located in a very strategic place. Gaza is on the coastal route between Africa(Egypt) and Europe. Right now there are approximately. 1.6 million people are living there; 1.3 million are classified as refugees (one wonders what the 300k non-refugees think about them.)

    When Israel was given its Independence by the United Nations (the same folks that subsidize the Palestinian refugees) in 1948, a war broke out between Israel and five-Arab states that surrounded it. Those states which included, Egypt, Syria, Jordan and even Iraq did not accept the creation of the state of Israel. I did not include Palestine because there was no Palestinian country then or ever, which is not to say there were no Palestinian people living in what is now Israel/Palestine. Those Palestinians fought with the Israelis. What we think of Israel now, had many Arab cities including Jaffa, which is contiguous to Tel Aviv. That war (and the ones that came after it) did not go like the Arab countries imagined. Israel won and took additional land. Arab leaders told the local (Palestinian) population that they should leave their homes, or they would be killed by the Israelis. The Israelis also took action to “encourage” the Palestinians to leave their homes. While it was not a pretty sight, these kinds of things have happened throughout history and continue to happen to this day. In the meantime, about the same number of Jews living in Arab countries were forced out. In some cases, their families had been living in these countries for over three thousand years.

     

    Heading South
    When the Palestinians left the land that is now Israel, they went in every direction. Some went to Lebanon, others to Syria and Jordan. But the unlucky ones went south to Gaza. They did not continue past Gaza because there is not much there until you pass the Sinai. When the War of 1948 ended in an armistice, someone drew a line on a map using a pen with green ink. That is how we get the so-called “Green Line.” There were three areas drawn – Gaza, The West Bank, and the Golan Heights. While it had been the intention of the UN when it declared the State of Israel, to also create a Palestinian State, that did not happen. Instead, Syria, Jordan and Egypt divided up the territories. To be correct, I would have to say that the Golan Heights was then a part of Syria. It was not a very populated area, and most of the people living there were Druze. But it was very strategic location, it is not called the Golan Heights for nothing. It is very mountainous and overlooks one of the most important areas of the State of Israel which is called the Valley of Israel. From 1948 to 1967, the Syrians used the area primarily for military purposes, firing into Israeli communities below. After 1967, Israel did offer the Golan Heights back to Syria in return for a peace agreement, but Syria would not agree to that so Israel d incorporated the Golan Heights into Israel and settled the land. By the way, it is one of the most beautiful locations in Israel.

     

    Why is there no Palestinian State? ask Egypt and Jordan
    Jordan could have easily agreed to set up a Palestinian State in the West Bank, but instead choose to incorporate that area into Jordan and even granted the people living there Jordanian citizenship.

    Egypt got the Gaza area which for a while was administered as an independent entity but then about ten years later, Egypt incorporated Gaza into Egypt itself but would not grant the people living in Gaza Egyptian Citizenship.

    So if you want to know why there is no Palestine, you might direct you questions to Jordan and Egypt.

     
    Six days in June
    Then came the six-day war in 1967. Israel won that war which resulted in Israel occupying the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights. In addition, Israel occupied the Sinai Peninsula, an area that is far larger than the whole of Israel. Israel offered to return the West Bank to Jordan in return for a peace agreement, but Jordan would have no part of such an agreement. The same thing happened with respect to Egypt. Eventually, Egypt and Israel did sign a peace agreement, and Israel returned the Sinai but by then, Egypt would not take Gaza back.

    Much later, Israel and Jordan signed a peace agreement. Jordan had no further interest in the West Bank. In 1970, the Palestinians living in Jordan led by Yasser Arafat staged a coup against the Jordanian King, which resulted in a civil war. The Palestinian leadership was kicked out and went to Lebanon where they tried and failed to unstable that country before being forced to move to Tunisia. That left Israel with the West Bank and Gaza, and no choice but to support the concept, if not the reality, of a Palestinian State.

     

    Tunisian Nights: Arafat arrives in the West Bank
    The Oslo Accord was signed in 1993 and provided for mutual acceptance of Israel and Palestine. Yasser Arafat was allowed to move to the West Bank and setup the Palestinian Authority. In 2000, President Clinton attempted to broker an agreement between Israel and Palestine. This agreement was an all or nothing attempt to resolve all the issues. It ended up being nothing. Most historians blame Arafat for the failure, but I think that just like the situation now, there is no agreement that both the leader of Palestine and a leader of Israel could sign.

    The result of this failure lead to The Second Intifada, which went on for about five years. In my opinion, this was one of the greatest failures of the Palestinian leadership. It resulted in the deaths of 3000 Palestinians and 1000 Israelis. It undermined the Israel’s trust in the security arrangement with Palestine. It gave license to the Settler Movement. I wonder what would have happened if the Palestinians had embraced the nonviolent approach of the American Civil Rights Movement instead.
    Israel pulls out of Gaza and gets Hamas as a reward
    In 2005, under the leadership of Ariel Sharon, Israel unilaterally left Gaza, which forced Israeli Settlers to leave. Israel left a number of facilities that could have been used by the Palestinians to build their economy, but instead they chose to destroy them. Then, in 2007, Hamas won a democratic election that was naively promoted by the Bush administration against the advice of Israel.

    Hamas was originally formed in 1987 as an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, an Egyptian organization that has been classified as a terrorist organization. After the Arab Spring, it did have few years of legitimacy in Egypt, and one of its members served as the Prime Minister until he was ousted by the military. The Brotherhood is once again outlawed in Egypt. This relationship goes far in explaining Egyptian actions with respect to Gaza.

    The stated goal of Hamas is the elimination of the state of Israel. By the way, it denies the Holocaust and does not distinguish between Israelis and other Jews.The Quartet (USA, Russia, EU and the UN) required Hamas to change its charter with respect to Israel to continue to get funding. It did not, and was cut off financially, but not from the UN. Hamas then began to attack Israel, and several mini-wars were conducted. Israel created a blockade to prevent Hamas from bringing weapons. This blockade which was also called the siege of Gaza, has been strongly condemned. Israel still allows for food, medicine and other supplies to be brought into Gaza. It supplies electric power and gas to Gaza. There had been times when it did not allow construction materials like cement to be brought in because it believed, correctly that Hamas would use that to build tunnels into Israel and Egypt instead of building homes, schools and hospitals. Israel keeps a tight control on fishing and other maritime activities because it believes, correctly that such activities would be used for smuggling weapons into Gaza. By the way, if you would like to understand the behavior of Hamas check out the actions of ISIS.

    The relationship between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority is not good. Once Hamas took over Gaza they executed a number of members of Fatah, the political arm of the PA as well as shooting into pro-PA demonstrators, killing many of them.

     

    The Worlds Largest Open Air Prison run by the most violent inmates
    The result is that Gaza is called the “Worlds Largest Open Air Prison” and I believe this is a correct description. Israelis blame Hamas for this. Hamas makes it easy for Israel to accept the tragedy of Gaza because they can conveniently blame Hamas. And while I think Hamas are criminals (they steal the people’s money) and a terrorist organization, it is not right to blame the people in Gaza for their own situation. They are the victims of many actions by both Israel and by other Arab countries.

     

    So it is time to stop blaming the victims and find a solution
    The first step is to understand that there is no way 1.6 million Palestinians can have a good and productive life in such a small area. The West Bank is about ten times as large as Gaza and has a population of just a bit more than Gaza. Gaza is not even 1% of the size of Jordan where, by the way, the majority of people are Palestinians.

    I can’t imagine what kind of economy could be created in Gaza, which would allow the people living there to have an appropriate standard of living. The area is just too small to support agriculture and the population to unskilled to for high-level manufacturing or IT services, etc.

    That means that the territory that is Gaza either has to be expanded or the population reduced (not eliminated if that is what you are thinking I am saying).

     

    My solution: make Gaza bigger
    Gaza is located in the Negev Desert of Israel and next to Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula. Both areas are lightly populated, and both are deserts. But Israel has proven as have others, that it is possible to make the desert bloom. Frankly, it does not take much. You need land, sun, water and energy. I could have left water out because with energy you can create water especially if you are located near the sea. Israel is a world leader in desalinization. Israel and Egypt have access to natural gas. I believe that it would be possible to significantly increase the size of Gaza and turn that area into a major agricultural center. Not only would this provide work for the people of Gaza but the food produced could feed Egyptians who have a major food problem.

    It would take less than five years to make this happen. It would require a large investment and Israel could not be expected to pay the full bill. But compared to doing nothing which will result in the continued cycle of war, it will be cheap. I believe there are many Israelis and others that would be willing to commit to five years of their life to make this happen. But the new territories would have to be demilitarized. I would suggest that while Gazan’s could work and live there, the land would be under the protection of an international group of countries including the USA. An international group could monitor the borders of these areas. It is important to provide living quarters, hospitals and schools in these new areas. The citizens of Gaza would be permitted to live there provided they accepted the international authority of a guardian. I am not sure that Hamas would allow the people of Gaza to leave the territory they control, but if they did not, I would think there would be enough internal and external pressure to finally force their hands. After a period of success, the new territories would become part of Palestine.
    Other alternatives suck
    I thought about other alternatives, like moving a significant number of the people in Gaza to the West Bank and then making Gaza with a population of less than 500,000 part of Israel. Such an action would require Israel to re-occupy Gaza, and force the move of 1.2 million people to the west bank. I don’t see this happening.

    I don’t see Egypt taking back Gaza because of political and economic issues.

    I don’t see the status quo. At some point, Gaza will have weapons that could inflict or will inflict real damage to Israel such as killing large numbers of people or destroying the airport. When that happens, Israel will take off their gloves, and it will not be pretty.

    It is time to use our brains, creativity and have the courage to act
    Maybe you have some ideas about what can happen. I believe that the problem of Gaza has a solution, and I outlined it. I am willing to devote time and money to finding a solution here. In particular, I invite my Palestinian friends to work with me on this project. You can contact me directly via email.

  • Reporting from the Facebook Frontline in the Israeli/Hamas War

    Of course, the real war between Israel and Hamas is being fought in Gaza and Israel,  but there is another front, social media. It is a different front because there is no real danger to the participants. But that does not mean they are not being injured.

    Before I go further, I have to say that the 100s of dead Palestinians, many of which are non-combatants including children, is heartbreaking. While Israel has only suffered tens of deaths, mostly soldiers, the pain this causes to the families of those that perished is just a powerful as it is for the Palestinians that have lost loved ones. And both Palestinians and Israelis are living with the constant threat although clearly the Palestinians in Gaza have seen much more of the realization of that threat.

    I am not going to discuss the causes of the conflict and who is responsible. The purpose of this post is just to reflect on my own experience of the Facebook Front.

    It is shocking to see how divided my friends are although I would say the majority of my friends are pro-Israel. I do have friends that have taken the Palestinian side and in particular my Palestinian friends.

    The weapons in the Facebook Front are links and photos and sometimes comments. Palestinians supports will lob dead baby photos. Israeli supporters will publish photos and videos of the Hamas Tunnels. There will be links to newspaper articles taking one side or the other. Very few of the post or comments from my Facebook “friends” call for understanding and peace or at least stop in actual fighting.

    As a Jew, I have been shocked by the anti-Semitic comments I have read. I am not equating being anti-Israeli with being anti-Semitic. I am talking about comments about killing the Jews all over the world. The stuff going on in France has been a shock. But I also see Jews including Israelis calling for the death of the Palestinians.

    I am myself a soldier in the Facebook Front. I try to make sure that I only post links that I have checked because a lot of stuff on both sides is just made up. But I find myself on the Israeli side. But that does not stop my from having empathy for Palestinians.

    Those of us fighting in this Front will probably come out of it was emotional scars. We will lose some real friends. Many people report that they have “unfriend” people because of their position on the conflict. I do not do that. I want to hear and see what people have to say even if I disagree with them.

    It is pretty clear to me that social media is just bringing heat and not light to the conflict.

  • It is hard to be a nice guy when you live in a bad neighborhood

    I have written a lot about Israel and Palestine, probably so much that I have bored many of my readers who appear to be more interested in what I have to say about technology than my views about the Middle East. However, this is my blog, and I write as much for myself as I write for others.

    Like so many others, I struggle to make sense out of the situation in the Middle East. In some ways, it is not possible, because it does not make sense. There are two peoples who claim what is, in reality, one land. Both have legitimate claims in my opinion but neither the Israeli Jews or the Palestinian Arabs recognize this. In their heart of hearts, they just want the other side to disappear. But that will not happen. Politicians on both sides exploit the situation for political gain.

    Israel grows stronger and Palestine weaker
    If the conflict between Israel and Palestine continues, it will not end well for either side. Israel will find itself potentially more and more isolated from Europe and even the USA, although I suspect its ties with India, China and even Africa will increase. Most concerning is the brutal way Israel treats Palestinians in Palestine that will effect the way Israelis view themselves. As a Jew with a very strong connection to Israel, I find much of Israel’s behavior in Palestine in conflict with my Jewish Values. But I also understand, and I hope to help you understand.

    The Palestinians are finding themselves with less and less support. It is not that the world is becoming more pro-Israel. In fact, the opposite is true. But the conflict between Israel and Palestine is becoming less important. World events are pushing this story to the back page.  Israel is in a position to extract a terrible price from Palestine. Israel controls all their natural resources. They can turn off the electricity and water not to mention the cell phones and internet.

    A Jewish State in the Middle East is not acceptable to Middle Eastern Countries
    Many of you, I imagine, think that if Israel behaved differently with respect to Palestine there would somehow be peace. I wish this would be true, but it is not. Even if the majority of the Palestinians would accept Israel’s right to exist (and they do not), the rest of the Arab world would not. No, the more than 300 million Arabic speakers along with countries like Iran, will never accept a Jewish Nation in the Middle East. For thousands of years, Jews were tolerated in Muslim lands but were second class citizens at best. But the idea of a Jewish state is not acceptable to them. And the more that Israel is successful, the less able they are to come to terms with it. I do not believe that the hatred that Middle Eastern Countries have for Israel would change if Israel treated Palestine differently. Interestingly, a growing concern amongst Arab countries about Iran may have more of a positive effect on Arab/Israeli relations that anything that Israel could do in Palestine.

    The Middle East: A bad neighborhood
    It must be clear to you that violence and intolerance plays a fundamental role in how middle eastern countries deal with conflict. Just look at Syria and Iraq if you want two current examples. The middle east is a very violent place with tribal and ethnic conflicts. The most well know of this is the Sunni/Shia schism. Here in the USA, we watch conflicts as those in Syria and see that there are no “good guys.” The side in power terrorizes the other side, but if the relationship changes, the other side behaves pretty much in the same way.

    The more Palestinians engage in acts of terror and violence the more they will be identified with the Muslim Terrorist. Please do not take me wrong. I do not consider most Palestinian acts of violence many which are just self defense, the same as Islamic Terrorist. But that does not mean that others will not conflate the two. Frankly, I think that most Palestinians have more in common with Israelis than they do with ISIS or the Taliban. One would just have to go to Ramallah to understand that. I doubt that Palestinian women would like to to be covered head to toe in black with only their eyes showing.
    Meet Netanyahu’s best friend: Mahmoud Abbas
    If Palestine had a leader that could get Palestinians to adopt a non-violent approach, I doubt that Netanyahu would survive in office. Both these men depend on the other to stay in office. If things became more violent, Netanyahu might not survive but his replacement could make the Palestinians long for these good old days.

    Is there something to learn from the Mexican immigrants in the USA?
    The situation between the USA and Mexico is not analogous, but there are some important things to consider. The Mexican’s in the USA want to be Americans even if they are proud of their Mexican heritage. In many parts of the USA, they are treated badly but they do not display hostility to the white majority. I can’t imagine what would happen if they began to attack white Americans.

    Israel the world’s largest gated community
    Jews have at least an equal claim on the land that is now Israel and Palestine. I won’t go into the history, but you can read my other posts on this if you like. Of course, the ideal solution would have been for one country in which Jews and Arabs lived in harmony, and that will not be. While Israelis love Israel, with the exception of the food, Israelis hate living in the middle east. So much, that many of them imagine that they are living somewhere else. I often joke that Israelis think that Israel is located somewhere in Southern California. But, of course, there are daily reminders that they are not. So Israel is building walls not only figuratively but in reality. There are three types of walls. The first is the separation wall which the Palestinians refer to as the Apartheid Wall. The second is the anti-missile defense systems along with other defensive weapons. And finally there is the “Apathy wall,” a psychological defense that enables Israelis to no longer feel empathy towards the lives of Palestinians. When I speak of Israelis, I should say that I do not include the settler movement. Many of its members seek to push the Palestinians out and incorporate what is now the West Bank into Greater Israel.

    Where has my empathy gone?
    I have not lost my empathy for the Palestinians. Over the years, I have thought a lot about what could be done to change the situation. I have reached out to Palestinians hoping to understand their perspective. I have donated money to organizations that I believed could have a positive impact in Palestine. However, I have to confess that I am moving as they say “more to the right.”

    I am very frustrated at how the Palestinian people have handled the situation. CNN is showing a very powerful documentary on the 60s, a decade that played such an important role in my life. Last night I watched the episode on the civil right movement. As a participant in that movement, I remember the events very well. I can only wish that the Palestinians would find a leader like Martin Luther King just as I wish that Israel would find a leader like JFK. Palestinians must learn from the American Civil Rights Movement. They must understand that non-violent protests can be very effective. They must resist violence even when violence is done to them. I know this is easy to say from the comfort of my home in Sonoma, but I do personally remember the days of being beaten by the police and taken to jail, although I will not claim to have personally suffered that much. I also recall with pride the role that Jewish people played in the early days of the civil-rights movement.

    No more Mr. Nice Guy
    I am not trying to blame anyone. I am just trying to look at reality. Israel is getting stronger, and Palestine is getting weaker. Resisting Israel with force will not end well for Palestine. The more Palestinians denounce violence, the stronger they will become. Palestinians should ask themselves how well have their leaders served them over the years.

    I will not justify Israel’s settlements on the West Bank or what I call the slicing and dicing of Palestine by creating the walls and roads which connect the Settlements to Israel and each other.

    What I would like the Palestinians to consider is, how would they be treated if Netanyahu behaved as other Arab leaders like Assad. Be careful about what you wish for.

    The future of Palestine is in learning to live side by side with Israel and Israelis.
    Fair or not fair, as long as they do not accept Israel and engage in violence, they will not achieve their dream of their own nation. Events in the rest of the Middle East are weakening the Palestinian’s position. They are also hardening the Israelis. If ISIS continues to gain strength in Iraq and Syria, I will not be surprised if Israel builds walls all around the country and also a wall along the border with Jordan. These walls will truly create a Palestinian prison on the West Bank just like Gaza is a prison with a beach.

    What we need is leadership both in Israel and Palestine that starts with the premise that both peoples are here to stay and must learn to live side by side. Sadly, I don’t see that happening.
    If I have to choose
    If push comes to shove, I will be on Israel’s side. The future of the Jewish People is at stake. Israel is an extremely small country. The Jewish population is just over six million people. Over half the population are descendants from Jews that were expelled from Arab countries after the creation of the State of Israel. Israel has no choice but to survive. I just hope that its survival will not come at the cost of Jewish Values.

    Surely, there will be those of you that will read this blog post and say that I am attacking the Palestinians and giving a pass to the Israelis. That is not how I feel. There will be those of you that think I am unfair to Israel. To the extent that I get criticism from both sides, I will feel that I may have accomplished my goal.

     

    Happy 4th of July but don’t forget our history

    It was not always a very pretty picture.

     

  • Good for the Jews?

    When I was living in Israel in the 70s, there was no such thing as cell phones or even the internet. But there was the portable transistor radio and everyone carried one tuned to one fo the few radio stations that were available. Once an hour, the news would be played. If you were on the bus you would hear the same report being playing on many radios. The announcer would report on International News. For instance, something about the Vietnam War, which was going on at that time. Let us say the reporter said that Saigon had fallen to the Viet Cong, everyone on the bus would say “is this good for the jews?”.

    I can’t help thinking about this when I hear the reporting out of Iraq. The middle east is clearly in chaos. The ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) which is a Sunni Terrorist organization that is so brutal even Al Qaeda does not want to be associated with it has taken over the second largest city in Iraq. It is likely that Iraq will break apart into three countries. One country will be Shiite and associated with Iran. One will be Kurd, and one will be Sunni and make the Taliban looks like liberal. But the ISIS wants also to take Syria and Lebanon. That is a pretty scary thing from Israel’s perspective or is it. Don’t forget that Hezbollah located in South Lebanon is probably Israel’s most serious threat. They have tens of thousands of missiles aimed at Israel. But ISIS will certainly wage a war and destroy them eventually. But then Israel will face them on its northern border.

    For sure, Palestine is a looser in all this. With all this going on, no Arab state cares about them. And with all this going on, how can Israel be expected to accept an independent state in Palestine, which could easily be dominated by the ISIS.

    So I am left with the question “Good for the Jews?”.

     

  • Israel/Palestine, my prediction for the future: A Palestinian State but no peace agreement

    In my last post on the topic of Israel/Palestine, I laid out a number of possible scenarios. It was not an exhaustive list. The purpose of this post is to suggest what I think will happen. But I need to make a disclaimer first. It is extremely hard to predict what will happen in this part of the world. While there are clear forces at work, there is also a lot of random events that can shape the future. Never the less, I am going to give it a try.  I could also not deal with each and every issue.

    There will be a Palestinian State…

    I have recently written about a number of possible scenarios about how the Israeli/Palestine conflict might be resolved/evolved. Now I am going to write about what I think will actually happen.

    First, I should say that the majority of Israeli’s believe that the current situation will continue for the next ten to twenty years. I do not. I believe that there will be a Palestinian State sometime in the next five years, maybe as soon as two years.

    …but, no Peace Agreement

    The Israeli Government and the Palestinian Authority will never be able to reach an agreement.  Both understand that the Peace Process will not result in anything. John Kerry was the only person that thought there would be an actual peace agreement and he has probably given up. 

    There is no agreement that would be acceptable to both sides. Maybe the two leaders could agree but they could never get the support from the other members of their cabinets. In the case of Abbas, he would probably be assassinated if he ever agreed to terms acceptable to Israel.

    So, to get around the lack of an agreement, Palestine will try to apply for recognition at the UN.  Only the USA can prevent this from happening and if they get a green light from Israel, they will no longer stand in the way. Abbas desperately wants to be the first Palestinian Head of State.  He is old and does not have much time to accomplish this.  Netanyahu understands that the time is now to have an independent Palestinian State which will allow him to focus Israel on Iran.

    However, before the Palestinian Authority can really declare its Statehood and get it accepted, Israel will preempt this act by declaring its borders, which by default, will become the borders of Palestine. Here is where it gets really interesting.

    Israel defines the borders

    Israel, having had enough of the negotiations, defines the Two State Solution and implements it.  They redraw the borders. Five or so major Israeli settlements are included as part of Israel. The rest of them are not and the Israeli government offers the residents of those Settlements financial compensation and provides new land in Israel proper to relocate those residents. In exchange for the land that Israel appropriates, land inside of Israel is made part of Palestine. This includes some major Arab cities now located on the Israeli side of the border. This includes such cities as Umm al-Fahm in the Galilee area. It has a population of 50,000. Right now the people who live there are Israeli Citizens and have all the benefits of that. While they basically consider themselves Palestinians, I would doubt that they would rejoice at becoming part of Palestine. Israel will offer to relocate them to other areas that will be in Israel proper and the ability to maintain  Israeli Citizenship if they move. If they do not, they will lose their Israeli Citizenship. Israel will of course build a separation barrier around these newly incorporated Palestinian cities.

    Jordan and Israel will set up a Military Zone in the Jordan Valley

    The last thing Jordan wants is a border with Palestine that relies on Palestinian security. Don’t forget, the Palestinians already tried to overthrow the Hashemite King of Jordan. So Israel and Jordan will set up a military zone between the border of Palestine and Jordan. Jordan will say they are only participating because otherwise, it would be just the Israeli’s and this way they can help protect the interests of the Palestinians. Israel will still control the borders but will agree to turn that over to Palestinians in ten years provided that Palestine does an adequate job in preventing terrorist attacks in Israel.  

    Israel allows for the immigration of Palestinian refugees into Palestine. Israel will allow Palestinians who live in Gaza and are not known members of terrorist organization to move to the West Bank through Israel. But until the population of Gaza is reduced to less than 500,000, this will be a one way trip.

    Israel will agree to any reasonable commercial relationship with Palestine for the supply of such things as energy and water. Palestinians will be given permits to work in Israel provided they are not considered security risks.

    Effect on World Opinion

    There will be a lot of outrage about some of Israel’s actions in defining the borders, but once Palestine has its own state and is no longer occupied, the world will slowly lose interest in the plight of the Palestinians.  

    What about the Palestinian Refugees?

    Israel will agree to allow Palestinian refugees from Jordan, Syria and Lebanon to enter into Palestine but will limit the number per year and will ban certain people.  

    Palestinian Terrorism

    It will be hard to prevent terrorism from taking place, but to the extent the missiles are sent from Palestine into Israel, Israel will have the ability to take defensive actions under international law.  Palestinians will have to decide if they want to have a modern and progressive country that seeks peace with its neighbor, Israel, or to become like Gaza, dysfunctional.

    Is this stable and what will come after?

    I do not believe that Palestine is economically viable as a stand alone state unless it can forge strong ties with Israel and with Jordan. In that case, it could become a fully functioning country.  If, on the other hand, it becomes a terrorist state, Israel will probably have to reoccupy it once more.  

  • Israel/ Palestine Potential Scenarios 

    Before I begin to discuss the various possibilities that can reasonably be constructed about the future of Israel and Palestine, I think it would be worthwhile to talk about the ideal solution.

    The Ideal Solution

    Israelis and Palestinians would have to finally come to terms with the idea that they are two peoples living in one country. By accepting each other, they would also be accepting, embracing and securing a future for themselves and their children. In this future, two states would exist but the citizens of both would be free to live in each country. Palestinians could live in Israel, own property and conduct businesses just as Israelis could do in Palestine.  There would be not “settlements”. I would expect that the economies of both countries would benefit especially that of Palestine.  There would be no walls. There would be no check points. There would be no fear and no humiliation. Palestinians could swim in the sea of Israel.  Israeli’s could walk in the historic sites of their ancestors. There would be one major international airport that would be shared between Israel and Palestine.  While Israeli settlements in Palestine would remain, they would be a part of Palestine. Taxes would be paid in the state where one lived. There would be no need for a land bridge between the West Bank and Gaza since Palestinians would be free to travel through Israel. There would be no Israeli highways in Palestine because Israeli’s would be free to travel through Palestine. Israeli’s and Palestinians would agree to certain land swaps to recognize the realities on the ground.  The Old City of Jerusalem would be home to the three great religions that worship the same God although in very different ways.  

    Lebanon and Israel would have a peace treaty. and together with Jordan and Lebanon, form an economic federation which would allow for commerce to develop between all four countries. A major focus would be on tourism. The federation would also strengthen ties with Egypt. Israel and Palestine would create a major program to develop agriculture in the West Bank and the Negev (Israeli desert) utilizing the abundant natural gas now found off the coast of Israel to power major de-salinization plants that would provide the water for such an undertaking.  Israel/Palestine would become the bread basket for many Arab countries and especially for Egypt which no longer can feed itself. Israeli Universities would open branches in Palestine and Palestinian students would have the opportunity to have the same quality of education as Israelis.

    I am afraid that this is a just a dream. It would require Israeli’s and Palestinians to trust each other.  It would also require each side to give up some of their previous claims. Israel would have to give up things like East Jerusalem and the Settlements.  Palestinians would have to give up the right of return.

    It could only happen if there were the equivalent of a Nelson Mandela and F. W. de Klerk.  Sadly, Israel and Palestine are very much lacking in such leaders.  So that leaves us with what is possible and then what is probable. That is now my task to explore.

    The Three State Solution

    The Three State Solution is what most people think of as the Two State Solution. The three states are Israel, Palestine and Jordan. This appears to be what the Palestinians are asking for.  I say “appears” because it is not clear to me that the Palestinian Leadership really wants this. I doubt that the Jordanian Leadership wants it and I am pretty sure that the Israeli Leadership does not want it. In my opinion, Israel, Palestine and Jordan are just going through the motions because they know it will not happen. The leadership of all three countries derives much of their power by not having it happen.  I have come to the conclusion that it will not happen any time soon if ever no matter how many times Kerry visits the region.

    The Two State Solution 

    This was the situation before 1967. Jordan and the West Bank were one country.  But rather than have Gaza as part of Egypt, it would become part of Jordan/Palestine. Such a country would really be Palestinian. I doubt that the Hashemite Kingdom would survive. Palestine would have enough critical mass that it could function as a real country. I have doubts that Palestine on its own has enough resources  to be an independent country without very close ties to Israel.  Such a Jordan/Palestine might be friendly to Israel as is Jordan now, or become an enemy to Israel, but it would be much easier for Israel to do with a real country – even if it was an enemy.   For instance, Israel has been pretty much able to live with Syria more then 40 years.With economic help from the USA, Europe and maybe Israel, Jordan/Palestine could absorb the Palestinian refugees now in Lebanon and Syria and integrate them, as well as integrating those Palestinians still living in refugee camps after 66 years.

    How could such a Two State Solution come about? I think it could only come about by starting with the Three State Solution first. In that case, the ties between Palestine and Jordan would grow stronger while the Palestinian population of Jordan (about 50%) would continue to increase as a percentage. Eventually the King of Jordan would fall and Palestinian leadership in Jordan would take over. From then it would only take a matter of years for Palestine and Jordan to become one country.

    The One and a Half State Solution

    Israel annexes the West Bank. Most Palestinians living in the West Bank are offered full citizenship in Israel. Israel remains with a Jewish majority but the large percentage of Palestinians give the them a great deal of influence in Israeli politics.

    Gaza is not made a part of this. There are a number of reasons for this. One is that adding the one a half million Gaza Palestinians to the mix would threaten the ability of Israeli Jews to hold a majority. The second is that after living in what has been a virtual prison for 66 years, and now under the leadership of the terrorist Hamas organization, an organization that does not accept the right of Israel to exist, it would be difficult to handle the security issues. Gaza would end up as its own country, one which would be isolated from Israel and from Egypt, the two countries it borders. 

    The One State Solution

    I am leaving Jordan out of this otherwise this could be considered another variation of the Two State Solution.  

    Israel would annex both Gaza and the West Bank. Palestinians would be given Israeli citizenship unless they had a history of attacking Israel.  Eventually,  Israeli Jews would no longer have a majority. The outcome  could be like South Africa where white continue to enjoy a high standard of living and have the respect of their more numerous black country-men. Or it could result in Jews being slowly or quickly forced into a second class position and eventually even forced out of the country. I suspect the later would be the case.

    Apartheid

    Israel annexes the West Bank and Gaza but does not grant Palestinians Citizenship so that the current Jewish majority can be assured that they can continue to set policy and control security. Disenfranchise Palestinians would not cooperate and there would be constant and violent confrontation.  Israel would loose the support of all nations including the USA.

    Blame it on the British

    You are probably thinking that none of these possibilities are very likely or very good.  I am afraid that is so.  You might ask yourself “How did we end up with such a mess”?  People all over the world are asking themselves that question about so many situation   So blame it on the British.

    In my next and hopefully last post on Israel/Palestine I am going to suggest what I think is the most likely scenario and how it will play out.

  • Israel/Palestine: The Future Part I-Key Assumptions

    We are almost at the end of my series on Israel and Palestine. All the other posts have dealt with the history and the current situation. My next posts will explore what might happen in the future. I will do that by first considering my assumptions in this post. The following post will outline the various alternatives I have considered. In my final post, I will choose the scenario I consider most likely and explain why. Then I will be done on this topic at least for a while.

    As my readers will know, I have been pretty good at predicting the future of technology. I am not sure if those skills are transferable to politics but I guess we will eventually find out.  I am also trying to express what I think is going to happen.  Please do not confuse that with what I would like to have happen

    Key Assumptions

    It is very difficult to predict  specific events that might have significant impact on the evolution of the Israel/Palestinian situation. For instance, I could not have predicted that Rabin would have been killed by a religious jewish fanatic. Much of what may happen in the future can result from such events. But also, much of what will happen will result from trends that are predictable. I am going to list some of trends that I think are key in considering a number of possible outcomes.

    America’s weakling position in the Middle East

    American’s primary interest in the region has been driven by securing its oil supply. America found itself in  this uncomfortable position because the key supplier of its oil was Saudi Arabia who, for various reasons (probably none of which really had to do with support for the Palestinian people), took up the cause of Palestine people especially as it pertained to the Israeli/Palestine conflict.  The USA also gave support to Israel partly because it was the only democracy in the Middle East, it was very pro-USA, but equally or even more importantly, because of both the real and perceived political power of American Jews.

    The combination of two really stupid wars in the middle east (Afghanistan and Iraq) have bled dry America’s desire to play a major role in the middle east. America is also currently operating under the illusion that it can be energy independent because of Shale Oil, an illusion that will probably hold for another ten years or so. This makes the Middle East much less strategic. Obama wanted to pivot to Asia in recognition of the growing economic and military strength of China, but instead has found himself in the quagmire know as the Middle East.

    The USA is no longer the preferred supplier of cash to what ever corrupt government is operating in Egypt. Saudi Arabia has taken over this role.  With the very important exception of Jordan, the USA is seeing its relationships with Arab nations weakening. And, it does not much care. With the eventual breakdown of the current peace talks, the USA will retrench diplomatically. Even Kerry, who must suffer from some messianic complex, will come to understand that neither the Israeli or Palestinian Governments really want an agreement at this time. They just go through the motions to keep the American government happy. The Palestinians also use the process to put International pressure on Israel in hopes of extracting some concessions short of an actual Two State Solution, which would probably be a death sentence for the Palestinian Authority leadership. Why does this matter?  Because the USA never really cared about Palestine itself. It does care about Israel because Israel plays an important role with respect to USA defense activities.

    Iran causes Saudi Arabia and the Emirates to move closer to Israel

    Hopefully you are aware of the Sunni and Shiite Muslims and they don’t like each other very much.  Iran is the leader of the Shiite World and Saudi Arabia is the leader of the Sunni world.  By the way, Iraq use to be controlled by Sunni’s until the USA started an unnecessary war and changed the balance of power in the region by eliminating Iran’s major enemy (way to go George!)

    Iran wants to be the leader in the region and presents a major challenge to Saudi Arabia who fears that once Iran has nuclear weapons, it will challenge the Saudi ruling family. Right now there is only one nuclear country in the Middle East – Israel.  There is only one country that can challenge Iran militarily – Israel.  So Saudi Arabia has to hold its nose and develop closer ties with Israel with respect to defense. Of course, no one will admit that this is happening. The same is true for the Emirates, those tiny oil rich countries located dangerously close to Iran. So it was not so strange to see Simon Peres participating by video in a conference dealing with Iran’s growing nuclear capabilities held in Abu Dhabi.  There he was for all to see, with the Israeli flag behind him.

    In the mean time, Saudi Arabia (Sunni) is trying to help the rebels in Syria (Sunni) to overthrow the Assad regime (Shiite) which is linked to Iran (Shiite.)  It is also trying to keep Egypt (Suuni) from falling apart. So the Israel/Palestine conflict, while still important to Saudi Arabia, has moved way down in priority.  Now that it is about the Saudi survival, there is little concern left for the Palestinians.

    What does this all mean for the Israel/Palestine conflict? I believe it means that there will be less and less pressure on Israel. Saudi Arabia will use what ever political capital it has with the USA for instance, to focus on Iran.

    Iran’s Existential Threat

    And what of Iran’s existential threat to Israel? I don’t see Iran attacking Israel with Nuclear Weapons. The clerics that run the country are not really crazy. They just like to talk that way.  Staying in power is what it is all about for them. Of course if they got atomic weapons, used them to attack Israel (with Palestine, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon also feeling the effects), they would find themselves attacked by the USA and what would be left of Israel (Israel has subs armed with Missiles.) 

    It is possible that Israel will attack Iran first. I certainly hope not because this would end up strengthening Iran and further isolate Israel. The Political powers in both Israel and Iran need each other to stay in power in their respective countries. The most serious issues for Israel would be things like dirty bombs via Iranian supported terrorists. But any attack on Israel like that would have a major effect on sentiment, thus freeing Israel to take action.

    Israel’s neighbors in chaos

    Israel’s neighbors, with the exception of Jordan, are in chaos. Egypt is a basket case and I should probably say “an empty basket case” because they do not grow enough food to feed their population and they are running out of foreign currency to import food. Only Saudi Arabia can keep the country intact. There is no way that Egypt can have any form of conflict with Israel.  Of course in their weakened position, they can not longer control the Sinai which borders Israel and Gaza. This will become big problem for Israel as terrorists will be able to set up basis in Sinai where they could attack Israel primarily with rockets. Under the peace treaty between Israel and Egypt, Israel cannot take military action in Sinai. This will not hold. It is even possible that Israel will have to retake the Sinai.  

    Lebanon is a small country with a population of only four million of which one million are Palestine and Syrian refugees. The country is very unstable. Hezbollah (Shiite) has a great deal of influence and really represents Israel’s greatest challenge. They have thousands of rockets that they have gotten from Syria and Iran many of which can be guided. I suspect that at some point they will used them to attack Israel’s heartland. Once that takes place, Israel will invade southern Lebanon once again and wipe out Hezbollah. Hezbollah has made some very serious mistakes and has been significantly weakened by supporting the Syrian civil war. By aligning themselves with Assad in the Syrian conflict, they have made enemies out of the Syrian rebels and turned much of the Lebanese population against them. They will find it difficult to hide out in Syria. Israel must eliminate Hezbollah.

    Syria has an awful civil war going on. Assad will eventually win but the country he will run will be weakened. All of his military efforts will be directed at maintaining his power. Israel will give Syria back the Golan, but will lease it back for fifty years, so in effect nothing changes to the people living in the Golan. Assad will sign a peace treaty with Israel and agree to stop supporting Hezbollah, in exchange for Israeli financial support. This will also make it easier for Lebanon to sign a peace treaty with Israel.

    Jordan (Sunni), only exists in its current form because of the support of Israel and the USA.  I believe that this support will continue.

    Israel’s economy continues to be strong in spite of boycott attempts 

    The Israeli economy is a power house compared to most countries. I won’t go into what an amazing success story Israel is, but the country clearly excels in so many areas. I expect this to continue or even increase. There are two factors that most of you may not be aware of. One is that Israel has discovered large amounts of natural gas off its coast and second, that it has become the world expert in desalinization. The combination is very powerful. Israel has the potential to become the food basket for the middle east. It can turn the Negev (and even the Sinai) into very successful farming regions.  

    There is no sign that USA/Israel economic ties will decline. The boycott movement against Israel in the USA is very week. Europe may be a different story, but I believe that any decline in trade with Europe will be made up by an increase trade with China and Africa.

    Anti-Semitism in France has resulted in many of the 300,000 French Jews moving and/or investing in Israel. Just a short walk around Tel Aviv, where so much high end residential construction is taking place, will attest to this.

    Israel’s military power will increase

    For such a small country, Israel is a very significant military force. It excels at the development of Military Technology from Drones to Cyber warfare. Most importantly for the survival of Israel, is its anti-missile defense and anti-terrorist capabilities. Many countries around the world are getting advanced technology from Israel, and in the case of the USA, jointly developing military technology.

    Palestinian Leadership will continue to fail the Palestinian People

    I am not impressed with Palestinian Authority.  I believe they are seeking to maintain power at the cost of improving the lives of the Palestinian people.  But they are not worse than most politicians.  It is just that the Palestinians need a Nelson Mandela.  I don’t think that Israeli political leaders are that much better but Israel has so many other institution that are very functional while Palestine does not.  Then there is Hamas to consider.  Right now there is not even one Palestinian government.  There are two.  

    Bottom Line

    Time is on Israel’s side. Arafat made a fatal decision in 2000 not to accept the Camp David Accords and to engage in the Second Intifada. Since that fatal decision, Israel has become significantly stronger economicly and militarily, while Palestine has seen its key supporters become weakened. In my opinion, right or wrong, Israel has engaged with the Palestinians  in discussions about the Two State Solution because of direct or indirect pressure from third parties. Left to its own, it would not consider the creation of a Palestinian State. I will explore what this means for the future in my next posts.

  • Israel and Palestine from 1967 to the present-the past or the future?

    In this post, I am going to attempt to cover the period between 1967 and now.  It is not going to be easy.  After this, I intend to write one more post.  This will be on the future.   I have not had a chance to have anyone edit this post.  So all you folks that keep sending me emails about my grammar and spelling mistakes and some time factual mistakes will have to forgive me.  Maybe you can you the time to post something of your own.

    I leave Israel today, after living her this time 3 1/2 months.  I don’t have a lot of time to write so I may have to give up being subtle and I will have to be brief.  Will not be able to go through the time line.  There is just to many events in the more than 45 years from the six-day war. I really want to write about the future and the alternatives I see so I am just going to list a few highlights to take us up to the present.

    Israel should not have kept the West Bank and Gaza. 

    Not only did this place the Jewish Nation in the uncomfortable role of being an occupying power but it also made it possible for the settlement  movement to take route.

    Israel should never have allowed Arafat and the PLO to take charge of Palestine. 

    Arafat was a criminal who exploited his people for his own personal gain.  Abbas who succeeded him is probably a well-intentioned criminal who together with his cronies are stealing so much of the money meant to support and develop Palestine. 

    The USA has not helped the situation by trying to mediate.

    Both the Israeli’s and the Palestinians use the situation to bargain for stuff from the USA.

    I know that many will disagree but I don’t see how the USA has had much of a positive impact on the situation.  Every American President and Secretary of the State with the possible exception of George Bush, wanted to be the one that brought peace to the region.  It is hard to understand the level of energy given all the other problems in the world.  Clearly it started out as both a love of oil and a love of American Jewish political power.  Now the only thing that the Israel and Palestine can agree on is that they can’t stand Kerry.

    The USA forced “free elections” in Palestine which resulted in Hamas getting control of Gaza and creating more a less a civil war between the Palestinians.  

    Hamas is a terrorist organization that has the intent of distorting Israel and pushing the Jews into the sea.  I have no doubt about this.  Gaza is an awful place.  It is a jail.  Its neighbors, Israel and Egypt do not want to allow open access to Gaza.  It is located just 40 miles for Tel Aviv.  Periodically, people there fire rockets into Israel.  Israel then goes back in and targets those responsible but since they often hide in civilian areas, Israel may end up killing innocent people who is frankly, one of the objectives of Hamas in my opinion.

    Most Israelis believe that Gaza is an example of what the West Bank would become if a two state solution was in-acted.  I think the Palestinian Authority fears this even more than the Israelis because the leaders of this organization would be the first to be killed.

    The Second Intifada combined with the increase in Settlements has pretty much distorted the chance of a two state solution

    Rather than accept the Camp David Accord in the Middle of the year 2000, Arafat, choose to renounce it and start a period of terrorism against Israel which included suicide bombers targeting civilians.  There have been a series of bad choices taken by both sides but if I was going to pick one that might actually may have resulted in making a true peace between Israel and Palestine, I would choose this one.   The result was a total breakdown of trust by Israeli’s in the concept of security with the Palestinians.  

    The second most destructive  decision belongs to the Israelis.  That was the decision to aggressively contract settlements through the West Bank which also required Israel to slice and Dice the West Bank with roads connecting the settlement to Israel proper.  These roads had to be secured and the result was chopping up the West Bank.

    Arab countries don’t really care about the Palestinians but use their cause for their own selfish political aims. 

    It continues to amaze me to see how little the rich Arab states have done to help Palestine.  And not state other than Jordan has granted Palestinians refugees citizenship.  This is the opposite of what Israel did when it took in more than 700,000 Jews who were expelled from Muslim countries.  Now with the Arab spring, the mess in Syria and the rise of Iranian power, even less attention and support is being given to Palestine which is  becoming weaker and weaker while Israel become stronger and stronger.  The only exception and an important exception is on the world stage where Israel is seeing more a more aggression against it policies including boycott activities. Israel does not like this of course and considers it unfair but if the choice is being “liked” or “secure”, Israel will choose the latter.  The question of course is can Israel ever be secure.

    .

    The Separation Barrier made Israel safer and created a prison out of Palestine.

    A great deal of Palestine is separated from Israel by massive walls.  These walls were the direct result of the second intifada.  Israeli general believe that the Walls  have resulted in a period of significant security for Israel.  Palestinians disagree.  But it is far more complex like most things here.  The Barriers create a great deal of anger amongst the Palestinians.  I would be angry too if I lived on the other side.  The wall makes them feel that they are in prison.  It slices up the west bank.   But I actually support it in general only because I believe without it, there would have been much more violence on both sides.  However, I do believe that they are sometimes place with the explicit intention of creating psychological  damage to the Palestinians.  

    The West Bank has a better economy, health care and education than any arab county.  The only arabs besides the Oil rich ones that are doing better are the arabs living in Israel proper.  It is no accident.  There is a lot of positive spill over from the Israeli economy.  Israel also provides a great deal of security for the leadership of Palestine.   But one could only imagine how much better of Palestine would be having peace with Israel.  You only have to visit Arab cities in Israel to understand that.

  • A tale of two Countries: Jordan and Israel, not quite a love story

    This post is not quite a part of my series on Israel and Palestine, but it is relevant.  For those interested in travel advice be sure to read the last part of this post.

    Map of JordanJordan was a very pleasant surprise

    Jordan was very surprising to me. It was more developed than I thought and I didn’t even get to the north and Amman. The population is very well-educated. English is taught in most schools.  The people are very welcoming. Even when people knew I was Jewish and that I was staying in Israel, they were still very friendly.  

    Jordan is a very large country, about four times the size of Israel.  But most of its population lives in a very small area called the Jordan Rift or the Jordan Valley close to the border with Israel/Palestine. Jordan shares borders with Israel, Palestine, Syria, Iraq and Saudi Arabia.  When you look at the map of Jordan, it is hard to understand unless you know the background on how the British carved up the Middle East.  With the exception of Syria, Israel and Palestine, the main population of Jordan is very far removed from the population centers of Iraq and Saudi Arabia.

    The country of Jordan is very new, only created by the British in 1922 during the British  Palestinian Mandate.  Prior to that, the area that became Jordan was under the rule of the Ottoman Empire for more than 400 years.  At the time of the creation of the State of Jordan, there was just over 200,000 people living there. The British created the royal family of Jordan by installing the son of the Emir of Mecca, Abdullah I bin al-Hussein, as the King of Jordan as a reward for his support to the British and as a consolation prize for the British sell out of Arabia to the Saudi family.

    Most of the people who were living in Jordan when it was created were Nomads (Bedouins).  The current population is now more than seven million.  About half the population are decedents  of the original inhabitants of Jordan and about half are Palestinians.  There are actually more Palestinians living in Jordan than in the West Bank of Palestine which adjoins  Jordan.

    The Jordanian economy is doing pretty well with an average growth of more than 4%. It’s main exports result from mining. But the country has embraced IT and is one of the leading IT outsourcing countries. Tourism plays an important part but has been hurt badly by concerns amongst western tourists about the Arab Spring and the civil war in Syria (more on this later).

    Map_8--Armistice-lines_-1949
    Jordan Annexes Palestine 1949

    As mentioned, Jordan along with many other Arab countries attacked the newly created State of Israel in 1948. In early 1949, an armistice was signed. The Armistice Line separating Israel from the other parties to the conflict was called the Green Line because of the color of the pen used in drawing the map.  It is interesting to note, that because of Israel’s planting of trees and development of advanced irrigation techniques, the border between Palestine and Israel is often referred to as the green line. This is in reference to the lushness on the Israeli side and brown dryness on the Palestinian side.  I have had Palestinian’s tell me that it is called the Green Line because Israeli took all the green lands.

    So, in 1949 Jordan was now in possession of the land west of the Jordan up to the Israeli border which contained the ancient Jewish Kingdoms of Samaria and Judah. It is clear (at least to me) that it was always the plan of the Jordanian King to incorporate that Palestinian part of the partition into Greater Jordan. He certainly wanted to also get the Israeli part but that would not be. So after the armistice, Jordan simply incorporated (illegally ) the West Bank into Jordan and gave the people living there Jordanian citizenship.  

    The West Bank might have continued to be part of Jordan if it was not for the PLO under Yasser Arafat.  And if that had been the case, Jordan would have clearly become the Palestinian state with Amman as its capital.

    War and Peace with Israel

    Jordan was one of the countries that attacked the newly created State of Israel in 1948. When the war was over, Jordan occupied the area that was supposed to be Palestine under the Partition (and Egypt took Gaza.) There were continuous hostilities between Israel and Jordan although they diminished greatly after Israel’s victory in the Suez War. Then in 1967, Jordan was about to attack Israel when Israel moved first in what is known a the six-day war (1967).  One of the results of that war was that Israel occupied the West Bank including all of Jerusalem. Israel incorporated east Jerusalem into Israel however, it allowed the Kingdom of Jordan to administer the temple mount in the old city of Jerusalem where the Dome of the Rock and the Al-Askar Mosque is located. This also happens to be the site of the most holy site for Jews, the location of Jewish Temple which was distorted in 70 AD by the Romans. In October 1994, Jordan and Israel signed a peace treaty that has lasted now for almost 20 years.  

    ArafatThe PLO tries to take over Jordan

    After the end of the six-day war, in 1967, a number of Palestinians fled to Jordan. In September 1970 a civil war broke about between the Palestinians, led by Arafat, and the Jordanian Army under the command of the King Hussein of Jordan. By the time it had ended with the victory of the Jordanian Army, many Palestinians had been killed. Arafat and the PLO fled Jordan and moved their operation to Lebanon (which created a disaster there but that is not the subject of this blog post).

    Although Israel offered the West Bank back to Jordan in return for a peace agreement, Jordan declined. Not only did they not want to make peace with Israel, but also because they realized that if they incorporated the West Bank into Jordan again, the days of the Kingdom of Jordan would be numbered. Jordan then began revoking the citizenship of Palestinians.

    Jordan and IsraelJordan and Israel 

    There is a great deal of cooperation between the Governments of Israel and Jordan.  I am sure much more than anyone in the public would know.  Israel and the USA keep Jordan stable in a number of ways including military, security and economic support.  

    It is not clear to me that Jordan wants to see an independent Palestinian State on its west border. I am pretty sure that they support the idea of Israel maintaining a military presence in the Jordan Valley so that they do not have to worry about terrorists from Palestine going in and out of Jordan. When I speak about Jordan, I am really speaking about the King and the other political leaders. The average Jordanian probably wants to see the Jews pushed into the sea since all they hear and see about Israel shows it in a very negative light. I wish that Jordanians would visit Israel, but the Israeli government makes that hard not that Jordanians are really that interested.  While an Israeli can get a visa to Jordan right at the border, Jordanians have to wait many months to get approved. The Israeli government wants to make sure they are not terrorists or want to move to Israel to get higher paying work. The US Government makes Jordanians apply for visas well in advance but US citizens are granted a visa at the border of Jordan without delay. The difference is that Jordan and Israel are neighbors.

    If there could be exchange programs for Israeli and Jordanian high school students, it would be wonderful.

    RefugeesPalestinian Refugees from Syria

    There are almost 500,000 Palestinian refugees in Syria.  They have never been given Syrian citizenship. They have been living in refugees camps for 66 years (three generations) and are suffering horribly during the Syrian conflict. While Jordan has been willing to accept Syrian refugees it has not been willing to take in the Palestinians. I suppose they think the Syrians will go back after the conflict is over but are concerned that the Palestinians will stay.

    On the other hand, Israel could also allow the Palestinians to leave Syria and move to the West Bank. I support that, but I would think that Israel would require those Palestinians give up their claim to return to Israel proper, and the Palestinian Authority would never agree to that. In this part of the world politics trumps humanity.

    allenby bridgeJordan and Israel so close and yet so far apart

    There are three ways to cross the border between Israel and Jordan.  The first is in the north and is called the Jordan River Crossing. The second is the Allenby Bridge Crossing which actually connects the West Bank and Jordan (more on this later) and  finally there is the Aqaba Crossing between Aqaba and Eilat on the Red Sea. Jordanian Visa’s can be issued at the border crossing with the exception of the Allenby Crossing. Israeli visas can be issued at all the crossings. If you are going from Israel to Jordan via the Allenby Bridge, you need to get a visa from the Jordanian Embassy in Tel Aviv.  That was an easy process for us.  It took about ten minutes to fill in the paper work and we pay about $50 each.  We came back a few hours later and to get back our passports which now had the visas.  

    The reason that you can not get a visa at the Allenby Bridge is because Jordan does not accept Israel’s presence in the West Bank. So their attitude is, if you walk across the bridge into Jordan and you have a visa, that is great. They don’t know how you got there.  And if you leave Jordan via the Allenby Bridge, they don’t care. They don’t know where you are going.

    Jordanian visas can also be gotten in Ramallah, the current capital of Palestine.  There must be an entrance to the Israeli boarder site from Palestine. I saw Palestinians entering Jordan at the final Israeli section of the bridge. This is the only location where Palestinians can enter or leave Jordan.

    It is strange that Israeli’s and Jordanians know so little about each other.  It takes longer to get from LA to San Diego than it takes to get to Amman from Jerusalem.  Israeli’s and Jordanians have much in common. They are family oriented and have very high personal standards. The emphasis on education and english in Jordan is completely in line with Israel’s emphasis.  Jordan is developing a strong IT focus. Israel is a leader in high-tech and needs access to the talents of Jordan.

    Jordanians of course, hate Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians something which I also do not approve, but compare that to how the Palestinians are treated in Lebanon, Syria, and Egypt,  you have to wonder why all this anger is directed at the Jews.

    Jordan Tourism Economics

    Jordan is a beautiful country as I have mentioned. I can strongly endorse it as a place to visit.  But its tourism industry is suffering because of fears by Westerners related to the Arab Spring and Syria. Yet, Jordan is very safe. It would do well to promote itself to Israeli’s and tourists visiting Israel. They could have a campaign like “Jordan and Israel” two countries for the price of one.  They can make it clear that it is easy to move across the border between the two countries.  And even better, include Palestine (especially Bethlehem) in the package.

    I was surprised when my guide gave me a map of Jordan. The surrounding countries were labeled on the map, even Jerusalem and Bethlehem were labeled but Israel and Palestine are not. This was not as bad as the map I saw three years ago in Egypt which just showed the area that is Israel and Palestine as just Palestine and had Jaffa but not Tel Aviv on the map.

    The Travel Part-My suggested Itinerary 

    My wife and I just spent three amazing days traveling in Jordan. If we had understood better about how beautiful the country was and how wonderful the people are, we would have definitely spent five days there. I am not going to write a travel blog. But I will take a few moments to suggest the best way to visit Jordan especially if you are coming from Israel.  

    I definitely recommend starting in the North and traveling South.  We used Indagare and Discovery1 to make our arrangements.  Our guide was amazing.  His name is Aziz Azayzeh.   He was wonderful. If you book through Discovery1, ask for him.

    Day 1)   Start in Amman and spend half a day and any evening, and overnight there.

    Day 2)  Go north to Jerash, one of the most intact Roman ruins in the world.  Then I would drive from there to the Dead Sea. There are some amazing hotels to stay in on the Jordanian side.  We stayed at the Kempenski, Dead Sea. 

    Day 3)  Drive to Madaba where you can see an amazing mosaic which is in the floor of a Greek Orthodox Church. It is a map of ancient Jerusalem and has provided many hints for archeologists, including clues that lead to the discovery of the City of David. Then visit Mt. Nebo where legend has it that Moses stood and got a view of the Promise Land, a place he would never enter.  On a  clear day, you can see Jerusalem.   After that, spend a night in Petra.

    Day 4)  Get up early and beat the crowds for a walk through the ancient Nabatean kingdom of Petra (312 BCE).  After that drive to  Wadi Rum and take a four wheel vehicle  to explore the this most amazing place. This was the highlight of our tour of Jordan.  I have never seen anything like it consisting of high desert with gigantic limestone Mt. We spent the night in a camp (5 stars). I have never heard such quiet.  The stars were amazing.  It was like being on another planet but one so beautiful.

    Day 5)   Go to Aqaba on the Red Sea.  It is a really nice town (nicer than Eilat in my opinion with several high-end hotels.) You can spend the day swimming in the red sea, visiting the local markets and enjoying a wonderful evening.  The next day you can cross into Eilat easily and fly back to Tel Aviv in less than an hour or drive the four hours through the Negev desert.

    We hired a guide and a driver.  But if you are adventurous, you can drive yourself and get a guide when you are in Petra (you need one there).  We felt totally safe.  Many Jordanians do speak english. The border crossing in and out of Israel is pretty easy.  It only took us 15 minutes to get in and that included getting a VAT refund and on our return it took 10 minutes to leave Jordan and re-enter Israel.  

    I definitely recommend starting in the North and traveling South.  We used Indagare and Discovery1 to make our arrangements.  Our guide was amazing.  His name is Aziz Azayzeh.   He was wonderful. If you book through Discovery1, ask for him.

    Here are some useful links:

    Amman

    Jerash

    Madaba

    Mt.Nebo

    Petra

    Wadi Rum

    Aqaba

  • There would be no Israel if it were not for European anti-semitism and British Self Interest

    There would be no Israel if it were not for European anti-semitism and British Self Interest

    This is a very lengthy post but please make the effort to read it all the way through.  It took a lot of effort to understand the recent history of the area we now call Israel and Palestine and then to figure out how I personally felt about what I learned.  I have tried my best to get the facts correct but I have likely made some errors with numbers and dates.  Feel free to help me correct these mistakes.

    Here are a couple of key points to keep in mind while reading this blog post.

    • There would be no Israel if it was not for European Antisemitism.  The Jews would have preferred to stay in Europe rather than move to the middle east.
    • The British facilitated the development of a Jewish State for reasons that were anything by altruistic.
    • It is doubtful that there would be any discussion of an independent Palestinian State if Israel had not been created.

    The terms Israel and Palestine refer to different geographies at different times. I am afraid it is pretty confusing. I am using the following terms:

                   Israel                      – the current state of Israel
                  Palestine                  – the current land that is expected to become a Palestinian State
                  Jordan                    – the current State of Jordan
                  Greater Palestine   – the combined area of Israel and Palestine
                  British Mandate     – the combined area of Israel, Palestine and Jordan

    ancent Kingdom of IsraelThe Jewish Nation

    The first mention of Israel goes back about 3,300 years. The first King of Israel/Judah was Saul.  His son David, made Jerusalem his capital. The last time that the Jews had an independent country was around the year 63, when the Romans made the kingdom of Judea a Roman Protectorate. The Romans destroyed the Temple in 70. The Jewish people rebelled against the Romans at various times until 132 when they were given the final boot. Jerusalem was turned into a Pagan City and the country was renamed Syria Palaestina. Prior to the Romans, Israel was ruled at various times by the  Babylonians, Persians and Greeks. After the romans, it was ruled by Byzantines, Crusaders, the Islamic Empire, the Ottoman Empire and finally the British. A small number of Jews remained through all of these times. There was never an independent Palestinian state.

    Many of you may will think that all the Jews were living in Israel/Palestine when the Romans forced them out in the 2nd century but that was not really the case. Jews had been spread out all over the middle east more than a thousand years before that. And Jews had began to find their way into Europe even before the Roman conquest. However, all Jews thought of Jerusalem as the center of their homeland and faced Jerusalem when they prayed. The Diaspora is the term generally used to describe the Jews living outside of Israel.

    The Palestinian Nation

    In reviewing the history myself, I would say that the concept of a Palestinian Nation goes back to the 1920s. Many Israelis point to this as a way of dismissing the claims of the Palestinian. I find this personally disingenuous. Yes, the Jews had a state two thousand years earlier and the Palestinians never had a state, but I don’t see what that has to do the right of Palestinians to have a state now. The people who are now called Palestinians have been living in Palestine long enough to deserve a national identity.

    Speaking of Genetics

    Recent genetic testing demonstrates that most of the Ashkenazi Jews were largely descendents of Jewish men who in many cases had offspring with local European women. This is not the case with the Sephardic Jews. Some therefore argue that today’s Israeli’s are not really the descendents of the Jews that originally lived in Israel. They point out that many Israeli’s have blond hair and light skin, although you can also see Arabs with blonde hair and light skin. In any case, this ignores that over half of the Israeli population is Sephardic and that at least 50% of the genes of the rest came from the middle east. Clearly the Jews have as much a genetic claim to the land the comprises Greater Palestine as the Palestinians.

    There is a lot of dispute about when the term Palestine began to be used to describe the people currently referred to as Palestinians. But recent genetic analysis would conclude that over 80% of the people referred to as Palestinians are descendents from Jews, Christians and other indigenous people in the area. The majority of Palestinians and Jews share the same Haplogroup. Like it or not, Jews and Palestinians are really cousins, if not brothers.

    In other words, some Palestinians claim that the Jews that live in Israel are not really descendents of the Jews that lived in Israel over 2,000 years ago.  Some Jews claim that the Palestinians are nor really from the area but come later and even came in response to economic development by the Jews.  This is also not the case.

    Is Jordan really Palestine?

    Jordan itself was only recently created in 1920 when Jordan, Palestine and Israel were divided by the British Mandate for purely political reasons. Some Israeli’s say that the Palestinians already have a state called Jordan, and while I agree that Jordan is largely a Palestinian state, for it to be The Palestinian State, it would have to include the West Bank. Please note that there are also about two million Arabs living in Israel proper. Most Israeli Arabs consider themselves Palestinians but that does not mean that they want to live in a Palestinian State. In fact, there are cities like Umm al-Fahm that are  located right on the Israeli side of the border that could easily be made part of the State of Palestine. However,  there are clear indications that those living in Umm al-Fahm would prefer to be Citizens of Israel because of the economic and possible social benefits it provides.

    Jordan occupied what is now Palestine as a result of the war of 1948.  They made the West Bank part of Jordan, and granted all the Palestinians living there Jordanian Citizenship.   This actually doubled the Jordanian population. It would have been correct at that time to say there was a Palestinian Nation. It was just called Jordan. But starting in 2004, they began to revoke citizenship for many Palestinians living in Jordan proper in response to the attempts to overthrow the Jordanian government made by the PLO.

    I believe but have not verified that, Israel offered the West Bank back to Jordan at the end of the six-day war in 1967 in return for a peace treaty with Israel.  But Jordan would not willing to enter into such an agreement.  If they had, we would certainly have a Palestinian state now on both sides of the Jordan and it might have ended up being called Palestine or Palestine-Jordan.

    Even if Israel was never established, I am sure that there would not have been a Palestinian State west of the Jordan. Syria, Jordan and Egypt would have just carved up Greater Palestine. After these countries failed to defeat Israel in the 1948 war of Independence this is what they did with the rest and no attempt was made to establish a Palestinian State until Jordan made peace with Israel in 1994. Jordan gave up its claims on the West Bank as part that agreement. It is not clear that Israel wanted that to happen but, in 1971, Jordan forced out Arafat and the PLO after what amounted to a civil war.  Jordan no longer wanted to have to deal with additional Palestinians.  If in ironic to me that if there is a single person responsible for not having a Palestinian state now, it is Arafat.

    Palestinian Diaspora

    Palestinians have their own Diaspora. Of the more than nine million Palestinians, about half live outside of the West Bank and Gaza. They are mostly living in Jordan, Syria and Lebanon.  A large number of these Palestinians live in what is called “refugee camps” (but don’t think tents think gated slum communities.) Unfortunately, these people have not been assimilated by their host countries in most cases – for instance they have not been granted citizenship. Jordan is the exception. The approximate hundred thousand Palestinians living in the USA seem to have integrated well into American society and many have become very successful.

    No matter what one might think of Israel’s treatment of Palestinians, they are treated a lot better by Israel than at the hands of their brother Arabs in Syria, Lebanon and Egypt. The large number of Palestinians that claim that their families lived at one time in what is now Israel is at the heart of one of the most difficult issues, “the right of return,” which I will go into in a future blog post.

    The European Jewish Diaspora, Anti-Semitism and the Holocaust 

    One thing is clear, the Jews that ended up in Europe had a difficult time to say the least. They were subject to awful treatment from Spain to Russia. Frankly, I am amazed that the Jewish people continued to exist throughout this period in Europe. Their population was very small at one point and represented less than 5% of the total Jewish population. I can’t think of a single example of a people who did not have their own homeland for 2,000 years and yet, continued to exist and practiced their region and customs.

    By 1900, the majority of Jews were living in Europe. They totaled a bit more than nine million and most of these were living in Eastern Europe. The Jews of Eastern Europe were generally poor and lived in small villages, as they were not allowed to live in actual cities. These villages were frequently attacked and the term Pogroms is used to describe these events. All my family came from such places.  My great-grandmother came from the village, Piriluki, in the Ukraine. She described such attacks to me when I was a child. But anti-Semitism existed throughout Europe, including countries like England and France and where it, frankly, it still exists.

    Jewish leaders decided that Europe would never be a safe place for Jews and began thinking about creating a Jewish Homeland. The holocaust proved them right. This was the beginning of what is called the Zionist Movement. The natural place for a Jewish Homeland was Palestine which include the lands of the ancient Jewish Kingdoms. The holy cities of Jerusalem, Safed,  Tiberias, and Hebron were also located there.  While the Jews had been expelled by the Romans, there were still Jews living in the “Holy Land” on a continual basis.

    In addition, the territories were under control of the Turks who had a hand’s off attitude as long as they could collect taxes. The area now known as Israel and Palestine had a relatively small population. It was anything but the Land of Milk and Honey, composed of mostly desert in the south and swamps in the north. The Jews that came to Palestine, came because they felt they had no other choice. Never-the-less, I am sure they could never imagine the Holocaust that awaited those that stayed behind.

    I am pretty sure that if it was not for Anti-Semitism in Europe that Jews there would never have moved back to the Middle East.  They would have eventually integrated in to European Society just as most Jews in the USA have integrated into American Society.   Instead, we get the Holocaust which resulted in the systematic killing of over two-thirds of the European Jews which represented 40% of the world’s Jewish population.  There  still less Jews in the world now then they were in 1940.  The Jewish population is less than 0.2% of the world population (unless you are counting Nobel Prizes).

    .

    1920-boundaryconventionmapThe Ottoman Empire (1453-1922) and the British Mandate (1922-1947)

    What became the British Mandate, the land that is now Israel, Palestine and Jordan, was conquered by many different countries over more than a 3,000 year period. As mentioned, there was not an independent state for more than 2,000 years. The last great power to occupy and control the area was Turkey. They held it for more than 400 years until Britain took that role at the end of World War I, in 1918.

    It may be a bit hard to imagine that Turkey was once a world superpower. The Ottoman Empire controlled much of Europe from Budapest down to the Middle East and up to Iran and North Africa. This included Syria (which included Lebanon), and Palestine (the current Israel, Palestine, Jordan and Iraq). There were no actual countries in this area. It was all one big Turkey.

    During this time,  the Jews, Muslim Arabs and Christian Arabs living in the region thought of themselves as Palestinian Jews, Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims. Muslim Arabs made up the bulk of the population. But the total population of all people living in this very large area was under a million.

    The Turks made the fatal mistake of siding with the Germans in World War I (1914-1918). The French and English realized that beating the Turks meant that they could take over the Turkish position in North Africa and the Middle East. In 1922, they got a Mandate from the League of Nations to officially rule this area with the objective of eventually establishing independent states. Of course, what they really wanted to do was colonize them.

    Balfour_portrait_and_declarationThe Balfour Declaration

    It was against the backdrop of European Anti-Semitism that prominent British Jews, in particular Barron Rothschild and Chaim Weizmann  (a British scientist), approached Lord Balfour with the idea of forming a Jewish Homeland – meaning an independent Jewish State. They even explored the idea of establishing it in what is now Uganda but quickly settled on the ancient homeland of Israel. In 1917, Balfour issued a declaration proclaiming support by Britain for the formation of Jewish Homeland. It stated that the civil and religious rights for the non Jews in the homeland would have to be respected. The territories the British discussed were Greater Palestine (all the land west of the Jordan River), which included what is today, Israel, Palestine, some parts of Lebanon, and the Golan Heights. France was not happy with this split and took a bit more of Palestine for themselves and added that to Greater Syria.

    How anyone thought that the small number of Jews living in the area at that time (less than 50,000) would be able to rule 10 times as many arabs, is anyone’s guess, but the British were really not thinking of a democratic country with a freely elected government.

    There appears to be a few rather bizarre reasons that the British supported the concept of a Jewish Homeland. First off, they were in a really bad financial situation. They thought they could exchange their support for a Jewish Homeland for financial support from the Rothschild family and other Jewish bankers. They also wanted support from the USA, and two of the key advisors to President Wilson were Jews (Louis Brandeis and Felix Frankfurter.) They also wanted the support  of the Russians. They mistakenly believed that because one of the leaders of the Russian Communist Movement, Leon Trotsky was a Jew, helping the Jews get a Homeland would win their support. At that time, the British did not even control the land in question which was still under the Turks.

    1922-mandate_for_palestine

    The British and French Carve up the Middle East

    If you really want to make a mess with established national borders, just invite the British in, although one has to admit the French were pretty good at screwing things up as well.

    In order to get support from the Arabs in their war against the Ottoman Empire, the British promised Hussein bin Ali (the Emir of Mecca) that they would set up a Pan-Arab state from the top of Syria to the bottom of Saudi Arabia that he would lead. This was around the same time they were promising Rothschild and Weizmann a Jewish Homeland that would contain all of what is now Israel, Palestine and Jordan. Get the picture?

    Later there was a civil war in Arabia, and the Hashemite and Hussein bin Ali were kicked out. Arabia was taken over by the Saudi family and became Saudi Arabia. To placate the Hussein family, Palestine was divided by the British into Palestine, west of the Jordan River, and Transjordan to its east. Abdullah, son of Hussein bin Ali, was made King of the newly created country of Transjordan.  Another son, Faisal, was made king of Iraq (giving the Sunni’s power over what was largely a Shiite Muslim country but that didn’t bother the British.)  There were only about 200,000 people living in Transjordan at that time, and they were mostly nomadic Bedouins.  Of course no one knew yet that Saudi Arabia had oil and Jordan had none or I suspect, the Hussein family might have fought harder to keep Arabia.

    Now that Turkish Palestine was cut in two, we are left with what I call Greater Palestine, the land west of the Jordan river. This was supposed to become the Jewish Homeland. Giving up the area east of the Jordan was probably not so much of an issue for the Jews since most of the areas they were concerned about we still contained in the land that the British told them would become their country.  Obviously, the Palestinians on both sides of the Jordan were not too happy to since they had also been told that the land on both sides would become part of a Palestinian Nation. Yes, the British told each side a different story.

    There was a census taken in 1923 that showed that the area west of Jordan (today’s Israel and Palestine) had 600,000 Muslims, 75,000 Jews, 75,000 Christians and about 10,000 others but there were millions of Jews that were expect to immigrate to Greater Palestine from Europe.  There was little concentration in cities. It was a vast unpopulated area.

    mandate-map-1British Rule (1918-1947)

    I am going to skip ahead to the Partition of Palestine that came about in 1947 but I want to point out a few things that happened during that time.

    There was a major revolt by the Arabs in Greater Palestine in 1936 against Jewish immigration and to demonstrate their desire for independence from the British. The British brutally suppressed the revolt and his created the seeds for Arab resistance that played an important role later in the war against the Jews. The Jews had their own issues with the British. The only thing the Arabs and Jews could agree to was that they hated the British. These feelings were reciprocated by the British.

    After the Arab revolt, the Peel Commission was appointed to understand what should be done. It was then that the idea of partitioning Palestine into a Jewish State and an Arab state was born. The idea was that both the Jewish and Arab populations would be transferred so that the Jewish State would only contain Jews and the Arab state would only contain Arabs.  While some Jewish leaders agreed, the Arab leaders did not agree. The British were afraid that the Arabs would throw their weight behind the Germans who were already attacking the British positions in North Africa. Never the less, the Arabs were sympathetic to the Nazis because they applauded their vicious treatment of the Jews.  The link between the Palestinian leadership with the Nazi’s is well established.

    To reduce the tensions with the Arabs, the British put a quota on immigration by Jews into Palestine. Given the events that took place before, during and after the WWII, especially the Holocaust, Jews were desperate to reach Palestine. Remember that the war with Germany ended in May of 1945. The Jews that were in the camps or in some cases in hiding, ended up in what was called Displaced Person Camps. They stayed for as much as three years.  The British would not let the Jews immigrate to Israel and only 50,000 or so managed to do that between the end of the war and the Independence of the State.

    The british who had been sympathetic with the idea of a Jewish State, turned against the Jews. The Jews formed a resistance movement and began to fight with the British as well as the Palestinians Arabs.

    The British were being attacked continuously by both the Arabs and Jews for their policies. They had enough and wanted to get out. So they turned the whole mess over to the newly formed United Nations who was now given responsibility to figure out how to handle this mess.

    mandate_for_palestine_paul_new_clip_image003Two People One Land

    The UN decided on partitioning Palestine. I don’t know what the other options were. The map they drew up made little sense but even so the Jews accepted the partition but the Arabs did not. The state of Israel was declared an independent country on May 14, 1948. War broke out. Israel’s Arab neighbors attacked.  Brutalities ensued on both sides.  In early 1949, an armistice was signed. Instead of a Palestinian Nation, Jordan grabbed the West Bank and Egypt grabbed Gaza.  Things would remain pretty much like that until 1967 when the Six Day war resulted in Israel capturing the West Bank and Gaza. During the confrontations, more than 500,000 jews moved to Israel. People that had survived the Concentration Camps and then the Displaced Person Camps literally got off a boat in Tel Aviv and had a rifle put in their hands and were sent to the front lines to fight the Arabs.

    The Middle Eastern and North African Jewish Diaspora

    Until recent times, most Jews actually lived throughout the Middle East and North Africa although by the time of the formation of Israel, this was no longer true. The largest populations of Jews were located in countries that are now known as Iraq and Iran, as well as places like Egypt, Tunisia and Morocco. More than 700,000 Jews were forced out of countries where they had lived for thousands of years as a result of the establishment of the State of Israel. So, while modern Israel was conceived as a homeland for European Jews, it now found half of its citizens came from Arab countries. Later, more than a million Jews from the former Soviet Union would emigrate to Israel. More than 50% of the Jews living in Israel can still trace their family heritage to Muslim countries.

    In my opinion, the Muslim countries that force out their Jewish populations lost a great deal in the transaction. The last country to do that was Iran in 1979 with the Iranian Islamic Revolution.  Most of the 80,000 Jews living in that country for over 2,500 years were expelled.  About half ended up in the USA and about 35% in Israel with the rest going to Europe.  They make up more than 25% of the population of Beverly Hills and are very successful.

    In summary

    • The last independent state in what is now Israel/ Palestine/Jordan was a Jewish state but that was almost two thousand years ago.
    • The Palestinians never had their own state but they clearly lived in Israel/Palestine/Jordan long enough to deserve one.
    • The Turks ruled the Area for more than 400 years which ended in 1918.
    • Jews in Europe wanted a Jewish Homeland because of Antisemitism.
    • The British agreed to help the Jews get a Homeland in order to get Jewish support both financially and politically.
    • The British took control of Israel/Palestine/Jordan at the end of WWI from the Turks.
    • The British wanted the support of the Arabs as well so the lied to both the Jews and Arabs and promised them the same land.
    • Jews and Arabs did not want to share a country with each other and still don’t.
    • The Jews and Arabs not only fought with each other but also with the British.
    • The British had enough and turned over the whole mess to the newly formed UN in 1947
    • The UN partition Palestine into two countries, one for the Jews and one for the Arabs
    • Neither side was happy with this but the Jews accepted it and the Palestinians and other Arabs did not. The borders drawn up were not stable in any case.
    • War broke out and the Jews were able to take about 60% of the land that had been promised to the Palestinians by the time a truce was signed. Jordan took the West Bank with Egypt taking Gaza. No Palestinian State was formed and there was no further discussion about doing that.
    • About 700,000 Jews living in Arab nations were forced out even though they have been living in some of those countries for thousands of years. About an equal number of Arabs left what  is now the state of Israel and in a sense were replaced with the displaced Jews from the Arab lands.
    • Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza as a result of the 1967 war.
    • Jordan threw out the PLO in 1970.
    • Israel and Jordan signed a peace agreement in 1994.  As part of that, Jordan gave up their claim to the West Bank and the idea of an independent Palestinian state reemerged.

    That is all for now. The next post on this topic will deal with the Occupation of Palestine (the West Bank and Gaza). It may be a while in coming as I am continuing to do my research, which include visits to Palestine.