Two Thirds Done

Thoughts and experiences of an eighty one year old Wild Duck.

Avram Miller by the sea
EN | IT

587 posts since 2006

Category: World Situation

  • Tribalism and me

    It has been more than six months since I have posted.  One of you actually wrote to me asking me to continue to write.  I began this blog in 2006.  For several years before, I was struggling to write a book on the history of broadband.  I discovered that at least for me, writing a book does not come easily.  I decided to write a blog instead.  I felt that this would help me developed the skills in research and writing that I needed as well as the discipline to stay focused on the topic. I believe I made a great deal of progress over the last twelve years.  About a year ago I began to explore writing a book.  This time I had an even larger objective.  I wanted the book to integrate the story of my life, my knowledge and personal experience in the development of today’s computer technology and finally, the knowledge and wisdom I developed through the many years of my professional career.  So far, it has not gone well.  I feel pretty overwhelmed with the task.  At the same time, I was dealing with a lot of life transition mostly resulting from the decision to move full time to Israel.   I have decided to go back to writing my blog for a while and then I hope to start the book.  I am now 73 years old.  Everything seems to be working ok (mind and body), but I am mindful of the time.

    I should also say that since the election of Donald Trump I have been pretty depressed about the future of the world.  Generally, I am optimistic, so these feelings are kind of new to me.

    Below you will find my first blog post of the year. It is a pretty serious one.

    In January, my wife and I traveled to Rwanda primarily to spend time with the Silverback Mountain  Gorillas. There are about 900 of these fantastic creatures living in groups of about 30 individuals.  While this is is not a travel blog (my wife sometimes does that), but  I have to say the time we spent traveling in Rwanda especially the two visits to Gorillas families is something I will never forget.  The trip to Rwanda also had the side benefit of getting me thinking about the role that tribalism plays in our lives and surprisingly to me, the role it plays in my own life.

    The Dominant Male (Alpha Male)

    Silverback

    Gorillas live in small troops.  The troop is dominated entirely by one Silverback male (the hair on the back of the male turns silver when they are around ten years old).  There may be other males in a troop (sons of the Silverback), but they are subservient to the dominant male.  All decisions are made by the dominant male who can live into his 40s.

    Humans are closely related to Gorillas,  The only animal that shares more DNA is the Chimpanzee.  They also have an Alpha Male structure. 

    The history of humankind also demonstrates the concept of Dominant Male.  Through most of our history, tribes of human beings have been lead by a Dominant Male although there have been a few exceptions.  Modern Democracy is a relatively new concept.  It is not clear to me that it is an enduring one.  We can clearly see the rise of the Alpha Male throughout the world.  The two strongest economies of the world are now lead by Alpha Males (Donald Trump in the USA and Xi Jinping in China) 

    See the behavior of Gorillas up close made me think that we humans may have a genetic preference for the Alpha Male. 

    Genocide

    Genocide

    Rwanda is a lovely and tiny country with a population of about 20 million people.   It is located just south of the equator but since has a very high altitude, is pretty tempered.  The land is lush and green.  The people are friendly. Rwanda is considered by many to be the safest and cleanest country in Africa. The government is run by Paul Kagame, its president.  He is considered by many to be a dictator albeit a benevolent one, an Alpha Male.

    tribes

    There are two main tribes in Rwanda, the Tutsi and the Hutu (there is also a smaller third tribe of Pygmies called Twa).  Something terrible happened in Rwanda in 1994. The population of Rwanda was about 7 million people at that time of which the Hutu’s represented 84%, and the Tutsi’s represent 15%The Hutu’s carried out the mass extermination of the Tusi’s over a 100 day period.  As many as a million Tutsis, which represented 70% of their population, were killed. 

    Rwanda was first colonized by the Germans in 1884.  After WW1, Belgian took over control of Rwanda.  Both the Germans and later the Belgians favored the Tutsi population and put them in a position of power. This was the standard method that was used by European Colonists to keep control over colonies. The basic concept was to put a minority tribe into power with the assumption that they would abuse their power and become hated by the majority,  This meant that the minority who was running a country for the benefit of the colonist would have to maintain the support of the colonial power to keep their position.  The Middle East is an example of this where Britain and France used this strategy extensively. The Tutsi population was just 15% of people living in Rwanda.

    To strengthen the divide between the two main tribes, the Belgians introduced a system of ID’s that indicated which tribe the holder belonged to.  Actually, there was not much of a difference between the two tribes. They all spoke the same language and had the same religious beliefs. 

    We visited the Genocide Memorial in the capital city, Kigali. It is a compelling experience. I have been to many memorials of Genocide especially those dealing with the Holocaust, but I was stunned by what had happened in Rwanda.  How much hate had been generated?  The Tutsi and Hutu’s lived amongst each other. Neighbors killed Neighbors.  The Hutu’s used machetes to cut off the head of the Tutsi’s. 

    Think about all this, made me wonder about the power of tribalism. You can witness tribalism with our primate relatives.  For instance, if two troops of Gorillas meet, the Alpha Males will fight. Same for chimpanzees.  I began to wonder if our own genes doomed us to follow in the footsteps of our primate cousins. 

    TwoPartyArguing640_3

    Political parties as tribes

    I was born in the USA and lived there most of my life although I am also an Israeli citizen and actually live in Tel Aviv these days. 

    I have watched the evolution of the two main American political parties evolve into tribes.  Winning power has become more important than standing on principle.  Nothing more has illustrated this than the accession of Donald Trump as President.  Trump does not stand for the key conservative values of the Republican Party but he won, and he is apparently an Alpha Male.  So supporting the Party and keeping power has played a stronger role than political principle. It is the driving force behind the Republican Party. I don’t think that the Democratic Party has made the journey to becoming mostly a tribal force, but they are on their way.

    I think I would have understood this phenomenon earlier if I  had been interested in team sports.  Clearly, teams are just a way of creating a tribe.  The goal is having your team beat the other teams. 

    n-ISRAEL-PALESTINE-628x314

    Tribalism  and the Middle East

    As I mentioned, I live in Israel and also that I am an Israeli Citizen.  I strongly support the state of Israel although I often disagree with the policies of the government.  I identify as a Jew.  My sense of being Jewish has always been my strongest identification and much stronger than my sense of being an American.  Funny, now I as write this blog, I recall that many times we Jews refer to ourselves as “The Tribe.”  We actually started off as 12 tribes.

    My wife and I live in the Middle East which is a very tribal area.  The modern countries that exist here were created by the Europeans (namely the British and French) at the end of WWI. Before that, Turkey occupied the area and the Indigenous people identified with there tribes and not their nations. You can still see this in places like Afghanistan and Pakistan.

    Amongst the Israeli Jews these days, there are sub tribes based on where families came from.  So we have Yemenite Jews, Russian Jews, French Jews, British Jews, Moroccan Jews, Ethiopian Jews and of course American and Canadian Jews. We have religious Jews, super religious Jews, and nonreligious Jews. But what unites us that we are Jewish, and especially that we are not Arabs.  The Arabs have their tribes too.  Even in the West Bank, there are many tribes.  But what unites them these days is that they are not Jews. 

    Tribalism and me

    I have noticed that while I am very critical of the USA government’s policies against immigrants and refugees, I seem to tolerate some of the same behavior from the Israeli Government.  Even writing that is hard for me.  I have noticed that I anxiously read anything that is critical of Trump’s handling of immigrants/ refugees but might skip over a critical article about something Israel is doing in the West Bank for instance.  I pride myself on being open-minded and fair but am I?  Does the power of tribalism overwhelm my values?  And if so, what can I do to reduce its influence?

  • Jerusalem: It’s complicated

    The status of Jerusalem as the Capital of Israel has gotten a lot of attention recently because President Trump declared that Jerusalem was Israel’s capital while not saying anything about its status as the Capital of a future Palestinian State. The purpose of this blog post is to lay out some of the facts that make the question “Is East Jerusalem the Capital of a future Palestinian State?” more complicated than most realize.

    I think it is only fair that I make sure that the reader of this blog, knows in advance that I am, in fact, a dual national with both USA and Israel Citizenships that lives in Tel Aviv. My point of view would probably not be described as objective.

    The Arab population of Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza is made up of indigenous Arabs and Arabs that moved into the area after the Jewish population expansion due to increased employment opportunities. Presently, the Arabs population can be broken down into those that are citizens of Israel and are often referred to as Israeli Arabs or sometimes Israeli Palestinians, Palestinians living in East Jerusalem, West Bank Palestinians, and Palestinians living in Gaza. Each of these groups has progressively fewer rights and support of the Israeli Government. To assume that each of these groups has the same objectives is an oversimplification.

    During the partition of Palestine in 1947, Jerusalem was to be an international city. At that time, there were approximately 100,000 Jews and 60,000 Arabs living in the area we now call Jerusalem.

    The Partitioning did not go as planned and there was a war between the newly created Israeli state and the Arab countries surrounding it, as well as with the Arab population in the disputed area. The result was an armistice and the creation of a temporary border called the green line. Jordan occupied the West Bank, and Egypt occupied Gaza. Jordan incorporated the West Bank into Jordan and made the inhabitants citizens of that country. Egypt did not grant citizenship to the people living in Gaza.

    There was a very significant war in 1967 – the six-day war. The result of that war was that Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza along with the Sinai which belonged to Egypt and the Golan Heights which belonged to Syria. Israel decided to annex East Jerusalem and unite it with West Jerusalem. Keep in mind that during the previous years, East Jerusalem was a part of Jordan and Jews were not allowed into the old city which is the site of the Temple Mount and the Western Wall which are the most sacred Jewish sites. It is also the same general area as the Dome of the Rock – one of the holiest places of the Muslim faith.

    By 1967, the Jewish population had grown to about 200,000 and the Arab population to 65,000. After the war, the Arabs living in East Jerusalem had the option of becoming Israeli Citizens or just being Israeli residents. Few chose to become citizens. As residents of Jerusalem, they also had the right to vote in local elections, but few took advantage of that which resulted in being them being under-represented in city government. As Israeli residents, the Jerusalem Arabs have the right to work not only in all of Jerusalem but also anywhere in Israel.

    By 2015, the Jewish Population was more than 500,000, and the Arab population was about 320,000. About half of the Arabs in East Jerusalem work in the Jewish Economic Sector primarily in West Jerusalem. Most of the Arabs work in the construction or service industries.

    The Arabs of East Jerusalem do not have to pass through border controls to work in West Jerusalem given that East Jerusalem is considered a part of Israel. They do have to pass-through border controls when visiting the West Bank. If East Jerusalem becomes united with the West Bank, the border crossing will move. Those wanting to work in Israel would be subject to the same controls now effecting Palestinian workers crossing into Israel for employment.

    Some would say that Israel does not provide the same level of services to the East Jerusalem Arab Population as they offer to the Jews of West Jerusalem. However, that Arab population in East Jerusalem are still significantly better off than most places in the West Bank. For instance, they have access to the Israeli State Health Care and Social Security. If East Jerusalem were to unite with the West Bank of Palestine, it is hard to imagine that the Palestinian government could afford to duplicate these services. The Palestinian Authority has indicated that they would consider an open city, but I would think that security issues would make this impossible for the Israelis to consider.

    Over the years since 1967, many Jews have moved into East Jerusalem and especially in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City. It is very doubtful that they would be willing to move nor could any Israeli government force them to do this.

    I have to wonder what would happen if the residents of East Jerusalem had an opportunity to vote on staying in Israel or joining the Palestinians? What would they choose, assuming that they fully understood the trade-offs? I doubt that they will ever be asked.

    It is hard to imagine that Jerusalem will be split into two again. It might be possible to create some international oversight for the old city, but I would think Israel would want to maintain security. Perhaps, the Palestinian Government would locate its “capital” in some part of East Jerusalem but would that make it a real capital. I can’t imagine a Palestinian State that would not have its capital in Jerusalem, and I can’t see any way that this could happen.

     

     

     

  • The Saudi Century? Part I

    A Clash of GenerationsIMG_0510

    There is a lot going on in my neighborhood.  The 32 year old Crown Price of Saudi Arabia is really shaking things up in the region.  He just confined 13 of his rich and powerful cousins (many billionaires) in the Ritz Carlton.  He closed down the airport where they keep their private jets.  I am sure he has stopped their ability to transfer assets (he froze 1700 bank accounts). One of the Princes try to leave the country by helicopter. It was probably shot down because it crashed and killed the prince and the crew. He caused that Prime Minister of Lebanon who is also, strangely, a Saudi Citizen to come back to Saudi Arabia where he resigned his position.  I think he is also under some kind of house arrest.

    Saudi Arabia is a pretty complicated country which I don’t understand very well. It was formed recently, in 1930 by  Abdulaziz Al Saud and has had just three generations of rulers.  Britain is responsible for creating this country as well as so many other countries in the region.   The current King Salman, is one of the sons of the original ruler.  He suffers from Alzheimer’s.  Which is one of the reasons he has effectively delegated his power to his son, Mohammad bin Salman (MBS), the Crown Prince. 

    The Saudi population is made up of three generations.  The first was not born into oil riches. Up until the 60s, the majority of the population was still nomadic. The second generation has only know an oil rich nation. The royals and other prominent people continue to live lavish lifestyles. They have transferred a great deal of the countries wealth out side of Saudi Arabia. You only have to visit Beverly Hills or London to observe this. 

    Over half the population is under 30 years.  Many of those under 30 have been educated outside of Saudi Arabia. They are connected to the world via the internet.  This is certainly the case of the Crown Prince, MBS.  This generation realizes that the oil music will not keep playing.  They even understand that Global warming could make living in their country impossible.  They understand that the second generation does not really care about the future and certainly the future of their country. 

    I believe that the arrests came because the Crown Prince was trying to put a stop to the transfer of wealth.  I think he wants most of the money of those he jailed, which is vast, to be returned. 

    What is going on is definitely a power struggle but one that is generational.  MBS has the backing of his generation.  He has a populist message.  He is risking his life in his effort to consolidate power and develop a strategy for the future of his country. I don’t really know that much about MBS.  I know he also loves a lavish life style.  But I also know that he is truly interested in creating a future for his country and a future for himself.

    One of the most interesting projects is his Saudi Vision 2030.  I hope to write more about this in another blog. In the meantime check out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tb7OveLpSzc.

    It is a beautiful day in the neighborhood.

    Saudi Arabia is locked in a battle for leadership of the region with Iran. In many ways, this is a religious conflict as well.  But I think it is mainly about influence and power.  Saudi Arabia and Iran have been fighting for years mostly by funding proxy wars. This is currently playing out in Yemen and Lebanon.  One of the most interesting effects is a growing alliance between Saudi Arabia and Israel.  Their mutual hatred of Iran is bringing them together. It also allows the Saudi leadership, which has found it convenient for the last 70 years to focus their population on hating Israel, to now channel those emotions towards Iran.

    Palestine is an obstacle to be discarded

    Saudi Arabia has never really cared about the Palestinians and would be happy to offer them up.  There are interesting signs going on.  The leader of the Palestinians, Abbas, just went unexpectedly to meet with MBS in Saudi Arabia. Would love to know what was discussed. Jarred Kushner was recently in Saudi Arabia spending a great deal of time with MBS.  Remember, Trump charged Kushner with fixing the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.  There are articles being written that Saudi Arabia is trying to get Israel to go to war with Hezbollah,  the Iranian terrorist organization that is also now part of the Lebanese government.  Actually, Israel would love to wipe them off the map, although this might not be the best timing.  The Israeli Prime Minister, Netanyahu, recently gave a speech in London where he seemed to stop giving lip service to the Two State Solution.  Saudi Arabia is in a position to provide enormous financial support to Palestine and surely some of that would pass into the personal pockets of Abbas and his corrupt government. The Saudi’s will help Palestine if this results in a way to recognize and align with Israel.

    Regional War

    But the big play will be an outright attack on Iran involving Israel, the USA and Saudi Arabia.  But first Trump has to deal with North Korea (and a few other problems).

    I think the other Sunni countries like Jordan, Egypt and the UAE will be happy to go along. 

    I don’t know what Russia or Turkey will do.

    Now, I should say that I give MBS a 50% chance of surviving one year. 

    I think I will stock my bomb shelter at my Tel Aviv home with some actual books.  Just in case we lose power for a while.

  • Israel/Palestian Post Obama

    I have not written much about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for some time. I was busy with the US election. The recent  UN resolution singling out Israeli Settlements and then the recent speech by John Kerry at the UN makes me feel that I have to say something about this very complicated situation.    

    Avram dual national

    For those that do not know, I am a dual American and Israeli Citizen.  Most of my life has been spent in the USA where I was born and raised.  I spent five years with my family living in Israel in the 70s where we became Israeli Citizens. My daughter was born in Israel.  For the last five years, my wife and I have been living part of the year in Israel.  We have been building a home in the heart of Tel Aviv (a liberal city which can be considered the “San Francisco” of Israel) and plan to spend about half the year based there.  Neither Tel Aviv nor I voted for Netanyahu.  I do not support the settlement movement.  By that, I mean settlements in what would be Palestine.  This area is sometimes also referred to as beyond the security walls.  I d believe Jerusalem is the capital of Israel and support its annexation.

    I don’t speak Hebrew.  People in Israel considered me a Jewish American with strong ties to Israel.  I know Israeli’s that do support the settlers and hoped that Trump would win.  I also know that most Israeli’s disliked Obama and did not trust him.  I am sympathetic to this view when it comes his policies on the Middle East. This is not because I think he hates Jews and Israel or is a secret Muslim.  I just think he doesn’t get it which is kind of strange since he spent a lot of time in a “bad neighborhood” called Chicago.  Perhaps it is easier for him to identify with the Palestinians than with the Israeli’s but still, I don’t think that is the reason he had the USA abstain from the recent UN Resolution.  I think he sincerely believes in the “two-state solution” and is very frustrated that he was not the person to achieve it.  He blames Netanyahu and the right wing Israeli government but somehow does not hold the Palestinians equally responsible.  Kerry in his speech spent about 45 minutes condemning Israel and about 45 seconds condemning the Palestinians. 

    Welcome to the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict

    Ok, I am going to give a short history lesson from my perspective but before I start I have to say one thing about the conflict.  Not only do people disagree about the present and the future but they also disagree about the past and not in a little way. Israelis have a totally different account than Palestinians about the last 100 years or so.  The reality in my view is something a bit more in the middle. But during this period there were lots of opportunities to adjust the “facts.”  So if you are on the Israeli side, your position is that the Jews were living continuously in the area for thousands of years.  If you are on the Palestinian side, you claim that your people were living in the area for thousands of years.  If you are Israeli, you see a connection to Jerusalem that is indisputable and goes back 3,000 or more years.  If you are Palestinian, you don’t see this connection and see the Dome of the Rock to be the third most holy place for Muslims.  If you are Israeli, you believe that your ancestors came from what is now Israel/Palestine and point to a lot of DNA evidence (I can certainly point to mine.)  If you are Palestinian, you say that the light skin and blond hair of so many Israeli’s shows they are really European (this ignores that so many Israeli’s came from families expelled from Arab countries in 1948.)  So so it goes on.  If you are Israeli you say that there were very few Arabs living in the area before the Jewish population swelled via emigration and created the economics that allowed Arabs from other countries to migrate to the area for work.  If you are Palestinian, you claim that your family has lived in the area for thousands of years.  To all this, I say, forget it. It does not matter. 60% of the Israeli population was born in Israel.  A great deal of the rest was born in Arab majority countries and forced out in 1948.  The people that created this mess including the British are all dead.  We are stuck with a really awful situation where two different people were promised the same land by a bunch of manipulative Brits.

    Why Israel can not agree to a two-state solution

    Most Israeli’s would agree to a two-state solution even if they believe that the West Bank (Samaria and Judah) are really part of historical Israel if they could believe they would be secure.  But they don’t.  What happened after Israel turned over Gaza really destroyed the two-state solution.  Hamas took over and turned that part of Palestine into a terrorist state.  For my American friends, just imagine that the drug cartels took over Tijuana and instead of just selling drugs to Americans and killing other Mexicans, they started firing missiles at San Diego and digging tunnels to enter California with the sole purpose of killing anyone they could find including children playing in their school yards.

    Gaza is about 40 miles from Tel Aviv.  The West Bank is much closer.  Now imagine you lived in San Francisco and the East Bay was held by people that hated you and would be happy to fire missiles at San Francisco and Silicon Valley including the San Francisco Airport.

    Most Israeli’s, including me, think that if there was a truly independent Palestine, it would be taken over by Hamas.  Abbas (the head of the Palestinian Authority) knows this and that is one of the reasons he does not want a Palestinian Nation. Of course, he says he does but he does not do anything to make it possible.  In fact, his safety is only made possible by the IDF (Israeli Defense Force.)  I believe He and Netanyahu are collaborators, only Abbas is better at embezzlement.

    Yes, there are many and a growing number of Israeli’s what want to make the West Bank part of Israel – but slowly.  While many, if not most,  Israeli’s do not agree with settlements past the barrier between Israel and the West Bank (East Jerusalem is a different matter) they have pretty much given up on the two-state solution so this does not matter much.  Yes, they understand that there is an international outrage about this, but so far that has not impacted most of the people in Israel. Their concerns are about the cost of real estate and the problems with parking.  It would be a different matter if they thought there could be a real peace with security.  But they do not.  They certainly did not trust the USA or Obama and for good reasons.  If there was a two state solution and then the West Bank was taken over by Hamas, what would happen?  Israel would have to retake the West Bank or suffer constant attack which could include the destruction of its only international airport.  Thousands would be killed, and they would mostly be Palestinians.  If you love Palestinians, don’t wish them their own state until they are capable of governing it. 

    What you have in Israel now is two political forces. One that wants to take over the west bank and one that does not, but no longer has a believes that a two-state solution is viable. I bet less than 30% of Israeli’s believe there will be a two-state solution which is probably a higher percentage than Palestinians.

    Palestinian Statehood

    There has never been a Palestine state, which is not to say there should not be one.  Frankly, none of the countries in the middle east have had states before they were artificially created by Britain and Frances after WWI.  Most, if not all of the Middle East is tribal (think of America before the Europeans.)  That is why you see so much conflict in the middle east.  There were no nations. There was no Saudi Arabia. There was no Jordan. There was no Lebanon. There was no Syria. The English and the French created these countries and others.  In doing so they did not respect tribal boundaries. In fact, they sought to divide up the tribes so they would not be a strong force. 

    Statehood and Democracy are western ideas.  The people that lived in the areas now called Palestine were ruled by the Turks for more than 500 years and then by the British and French.  That does not mean that there should not be a Palestinian state but it is important to understand that such a state never existed.  That is not the same as saying that Palestinian people did not exist and do not have the right to their own state.

    So now the people that live in the West Bank and the people that live in Gaza want an independent state but hey don’t seem to want the same one.  Please keep in mind the Palestinians in the West Bank and in Gaza have two different governments.  Most of them want just one state from Jordan to the Mediterranean which includes the area occupied by Israel. They are willing to accept an independent country called Israel, provided that descendants of the people that lived in that area prior to the war in 1948 could return.  If that happened, such a country would be a majority of Arabs. Then, if the majority of Israel was not Jewish, Israel, by definition would not be a Jewish State. So in the meantime, which has been almost 70 years, they and their descendants and the descendants of their descendants have been living in refugee camps support by guess who? the United Nations.  In the meantime, an equal number of Jews were expelled from Arab countries and have been fully integrated into Israel.

    The Palestinians have also not been willing to accept Jews as citizens of Palestine.  Israel has an Arab population of 20%.  Would Palestine be willing to have a Jewish population of 20%?  I doubt it.  Just look at what has happened to the Christian populations in Palestine.

    So what does all this mean?

    For Israeli’s, security is number one.  There will never be a two-state solution without convincing Israelis that they and their families will be safe. So far, no one has made any proposals that would make Israeli’s feel safe.  I certainly have heard no proposals from Kerry or Obama.  All the lecturing is meaningless without that.  Kerry is worried that the Settler Movement will make such a two-state solution impossible.  I think he is right.  But he did nothing to deal with the real issues and his speech did nothing either.  If you want Israeli’s to support a two-state solution, you have to really address their security needs.  I have seen nothing put forward that deals with that.

    Palestinians have been raised on a diet of hatred against Israel and Jews.  Yet, when you put individuals together, they can often feel comfortable.  Palestinians actually have much more in common with Israeli’s then they do with Saudi’s.  My experience with Palestinians has been very positive.  I am a supporter of various nonprofits helping Palestinian students and personally have provided funding to individual Palestinians.  Frankly, I would rather do something on a grander scale but have never found a way, but I continue to try.

    What going to happen?

    The can is going to be kicked down the road again.  No one is willing to take a chance on the other and for very good reasons.  Israel is becoming stronger and Palestine weaker.  Frankly, with the exception of Europeans who themselves are getting weaker and some on the left in the USA, no one, least of all the Arab countries, cares about the Palestinians.  Yes, Palestine can get the UN to pass resolutions but they will have little effect on Israel.  Many of the 15 countries that voted for the UN proposal against Israel have strong business relationships with Israel and I doubt that they will weaken.  There are now weekly flights between Saudi Arabia and Israeli for instance.

    Goodbye Obama and Kerry

    I am a democrat and voted for Obama twice and for Clinton in the last election. Trump disgusts me as a human being and I can’t stand that he was elected president.  Now that I’ve  gotten that out of the way, I need to say that I am very critical of Obama’s foreign policy. Obama has a big ego (maybe as big as Trump) but shows it differently.  He had all these ideas for his legacy.  Not only did he want to provide health care for all but he was going to solve the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.  He accomplished nothing with Israel.  In the last four years, he got Kerry to carry his water.  Kerry understood the issues academically but had no idea how to fix anything.  Finally, he gave his pedantic speech at the UN in which he spent 45 minutes blasting Israel and 45 seconds blasting the Palestinians.  What was his intention?  Maybe to get a future job at the UN.  He certainly had zero or a negative effect on the peace process. 

    Enter Trump

    I may be wrong, but it is hard for me to imagine he will spend much time or political capital on Israel/Palestine. He will generally take the Israeli side but won’t really do much.  Netanyahu will become Trumps bitch.  He will be scared to cross him. 

    The one hope I had when Trump was elected is that the Palestinians would realize that things would not get better and they should make a deal, but then I reminded myself that any deal would result in the death of Mahmoud Abbas (literally.)

    Here is my breakout strategy

    I think the Israeli government is waiting for events that will give them some cover with a breakout strategy.  Unfortunately, I think this means some serious terrorism from the West Bank,  and I think that Israel ultimately will take over the West Bank. It will give the people living there a path to citizenship which might take ten years. Israel will not take over Gaza.  So we had a notion of a two-state solution but it turned out to be Greater Israel and Palestinian Gaza.  Israel and Egypt will offer Gaza additional land (maybe increasing the land mass by three times) which will allow the people of Gaza land to expand, have better living conditions, farming and better business opportunities. If Israel makes serious investments in infrastructure in the West Bank to the benefit of the people living there along with other economic incentives, things might just work out but not without a great deal of pain for both sides. 

    I know I am being optimistic but I am writing this on New Year’s day.  If I can’t be optimistic this day, then when?  And if you don’t like what I am saying then please give my not only your criticism but also your point of view and better yet your proposals.

  • The Iran deal…is it the beginning of the end? or the end of the beginning?

    I  really don’t know how I feel about the deal with Iran.  I tend to look at this situation from the eyes of an American/Israeli and the existential threat that a nuclear Iran represents. Through these eyes, it looks like the beginning of the end. The end of Israel. Once Iran demonstrates that it has an atomic bomb, everyone in Israel that has a foreign passport, and there are many, will leave the country.  But through the eyes of an American who is probably not risking the future of his children, it could be the beginning of a new Iran.  Iran is a great country lead by some awful people.  It has so much potential.

    In the short term, the deal agreed to by Obama, which could be stopped by congressional action, will make Israel safer.  I think Iran will be on its good behavior for a while, at least with respect to atomic weapons. 

    This makes Israel the only nuclear power in the middle east.  It also makes Israel the only power that can challenge Iran if it should get nuclear weapons.  That is one of the reasons that Arab countries like Saudi Arabia are holding their noses and making secret deals with Israel.

    The USA will probably try to make up with Israel, especially in time for the Presidential Election.  The Democrats will need Jewish financial support (we don’t have enough people to matter when it comes to votes.)  I doubt that they will put any pressure on Israel to deal with the Palestinians.  The Republicans, who are supported by the Zionist Christians, certainly will not put pressure on Israel.  I am sure that Netanyahu and Abbas called each other up and expressed their hope that Kerry would not be coming back to the region for a while.

    Iran will go after ISIS even harder.  They love a situation where they can kill Sunnis and have the world’s applause. Israel is probably giving intelligence about ISIS activities just as they give ISIS info on Iran’s activities.  

    Oil prices will continue to go down.  This will really hurt Russia, so it is hard to understand why they supported this agreement. There must be something being offered to Russia and China to see them so cooperative. 

    If the deal goes through, Obama will go down in history as either a very courageous man that took risk to keep the USA out of another war and prevent Iran from getting the bomb (at least for a long time) or, as one of the greatest fools of all time for dropping the sanctions and trusting Iran.  At least the man has guts.

    Perhaps, Iran will slowly turn to the west.  Their people clearly want that.  A man can dream!

    The loser in all this is Netanyahu in my opinion.  He showed that he could not stop the USA from doing this deal, and now that it is done (pretty much), he will have to turn his attention to  domestic issues and there are many. 

    The Palestinians continue to see their position weakened even though Europe talks a good game.  No one really cares.  Israel is busy making sure that Hamas and the PLO never get together, playing off of their greed, corruption and the  hatred of each other.

    It will probably be a few months or more before the deal is signed.  This gives us all a lot of time to decide if this is a good deal or a bad deal.  No matter what we think know, we will not really know for many years.

  • If you don’t like the Jewish settlements in the West Bank, blame Jesus!

    Those that are regular readers of this blog, know that I think and write often about the Israeli/Palestine conflict.  I thought I had a deep knowledge of this subject and was really surprised when I learned about the importance of the Christian Zionist movement.

    About seventy million evangelist born-again Christians in the United States believe that the gathering of the Jews in their biblical homeland is a prerequisite for the Second Coming of Christ.   The original homeland includes Samaria and Judah which is inconvenient since this is where the West Bank/Palestine, is located.  About 40% of all tourists to Israel or, the Holly Land as  these particular tourists call it, are born again Christians.  They spend a few weeks traveling around Israel, the West Bank, Jordan, and visiting biblical sites.  They never visit Tel Aviv where I live part of the year.  If they did, they would be shocked to see what has become of the “People of the Book” in one of the hottest cities in the world (think Miami Beach with smart people.)  It’s full of great restaurants that never close, sexy soldiers in bikinis at the beach, and they have their own  as well as gay pride parades. 

    The End of Days,  Armageddon and the Rapture

    This part of the post is a bit difficult to write.  I am trying to respect the religious views of all people and frankly, all religions including mine are full of what I think is fantastical thinking.  However, I do have to list some key concepts because they actually affect the political situation in Israel and Palestine. So the basic concept of Armageddon is that armies in the region, led by some really bad dudes (think ISIS), attack the Israeli’s in the North of Israel at a place called Megiddo.  I have been there to Meggido, it is a beautiful area  which was important thousands of years ago because of its location. Not much is happening there now.  It is hard to imagine that this is where the “End of Days” will begin.  Armageddon is a Greek word derived from the Hebrew “Har Megiddo” or the Mountains of Megiddo.  They believe the armies are led by the antichrist who attack the Jews who are almost wiped out by these evil forces.   Jesus has to come back to earth to defeat  them and save his people, the Christians.

    Israel Jesus Map

    Evidently, those that are Born Again get to go to heaven, and those that are not are sent to hell.   This is called the Rapture.  Jews are given a special opportunity: they can finally accept Jesus as the true son of God and the Messiah and be reborn, or go to hell with the rest of their friends.  About a third of the Jews admit they have had it wrong for the last 2,000 years and fly up to heaven.  Now there are no Jews left which has been the goal of some other folks in the past.

    Influence on Israeli Politics

    If I ask you what the most powerful lobby group is in the USA supporting Israel, you would probably say APAC. This is what I would have said until last Sunday when I was watching an episode of Vice on HBO. It turns out that the largest support for Israel comes from the Christian Right.  Not only do they support Israel per se, but they are against an independent Palestinian State.   

    Netanyahu understands this very well.  He knows that much of this support could vanish if there was a political settlement with the Palestinians which created an actual non-Jewish State in the ancient homeland of the Jews.  While the Jewish Lobby, APAC, does not make direct contributions to individual members of Congress, the Christian Right does.

    The Settlers and the Christians

    The Settler movement also understands the motivations of the Christian Right very well.  Not only do they benefit from the political support of these American Christians, but they also get direct economic support from the many tourists that visit them.  They even provide free labor to help construct them.  By the way, much of the support that the Christians provide to Israel is tax deductible.

    Effect on the Two State Solution?

    The situation is very complicated between the Israelis and Palestinians. The Settlements are just one of many issues. It is a very important one and the one that draws a lot of negative attention to Israel.  The Right of Return for Palestinian refugees, the status of Jerusalem, and Israeli security are others. I am very doubtful that there will ever be a Palestinian state. The Christian Right is not the only force supporting the Settlements, but it is a very important force and one that is generally, poorly understood. 

    Now that I have learned about this, I will try to factor this into my future posts on the topic of Israel and Palestine.

    Jesus and the Settlements

    Frankly, I don’t know much about the teachings of Jesus but I am pretty sure he can not really be blamed for the problems between the Israeli’s and the Palestinians.  That honor belongs to the British. 

  • Thoughts once again about Israel and Palestine

    Periodically, I make the mistake of posting something about the Palestinian/Israeli conflict on Facebook.  This often results in a long dialog by various Facebook “friends”.  I join in a bit.  However, I thought this time,  I would open it up to you my blog as readers as well as my Facebook “friends”.
    Democracy in the Middle East and North Africa
    The Middle East and North Africa, with the exception of Israel, is not capable of being democratic, sadly. This does not have to do so much with the predominant religion, Islam, the culture of the people or even the hot sun. It is the result of actions taken by western powers over the years. First the British and French explicitly screw things up by carving up the territory, they got from the Turk at the end of World War I, in ways that would benefit them and keep them colonial power in the region.

    How did we get this mess
    After WWII, Europe decided it would be better to let their remaining Jews emigrate to Palestine rather than have to deal with their collective guilt resulting in their complicity in the holocaust and anyway, they really did not like Jews and were glad to get rid of them. At that time, they cared even less for the Arabs, so they had no real concern for what would result from the immigration of European Jews to the region. By this time, there were many Jews that had moved to Palestine which was sparsely populated.

    After WWII, England and France were no longer the powers they once were. Keeping their control over the Middle East was too expensive. England decided to dump the problem of Palestine (which at that time was at that time one area which contained both what is today, Israel and the West Bank) in the laps of the newly formed United Nations. The result was the partitioning of greater Palestine into Israel and Palestine. Then the war of independence started. The Jews were attacked by Jordan, Egypt, Syria, and a few other Arab countries. Palestinians were told to leave by their leaders and in some cases, they were forced out by the Jews. Eventually, there was an armistice and the pre-1967 war, border was established. Rather than getting a country of their own, the Palestinians on the West Bank of the Jordan river were made citizens of a greater Jordan. Gaza which was a small and sleepy fishing village which was swelled in numbers because of refugees from Israel giving up beautiful land and homes in places like Yafo, for squalor of Gaza became part of Egypt but those living there were made stateless by the Egyptians.

    Most Arab nations (not Iran which is not an Arab nation) expelled their Jewish Citizens which had the unintended consequences of strengthening the Jewish State. It was not until the religious fanatics took over Iran, that most of the Iranian Jews left to colonize Beverly Hills. The plight of Palestinians which left Israel on their own or were forced out (one can debate the relative numbers) gets a lot of attention. This is because, after three generations, most are still living as refugees thanks to the UN support. Arab countries have been unwilling to absorb the Palestinians. The plight of Jews forced out of Arab countries is not discussed because they have been fully integrated into Israel.

    Keeping the West Bank and Gaza was a terrible mistake by Israel
    After the 1967 war, Israel made a terrible decision to hold onto the West Bank and Gaza with the hopes that they could trade those lands for Peace with Jordan and with Egypt. By the time peace with those two countries came, neither Jordan or Egypt were interested in getting back the land they administered prior to 1967. Arafat for instance tried to overthrow the King of Jordan and started a civil war there. By the way, there was no Palestinian State. Palestinians have gotten more governmental control under Israeli occupation than they ever had under the Jordanians or Egyptians.

    While it made sense for Israel to use its military to provide security in the West Bank and Gaza, political forces in Israel involving both economics and religious factions resulted in the settlements and the building of roads for Israeli’ through the territories which I refer to as the slicing and dicing of Palestine.

    Who really cares about the Palestinians
    Arab countries treat the Palestinians that lived in their countries as second-class citizens or worse. They accused Israel of crimes against the Palestinians but force them to stay in refugee camps. They used hatred against Israel and the Jews to strengthen their own political positions.

    Palestinian Leadership
    Israel gave up Gaza which was taken over by a bunch of gangsters (I can’t call them terrorists because they give terrorists a bad name), Hamas. Hamas came into power because the USA pushed for democratic elections against the advice of Israel. Please note
    that there has not been an election in the West Bank for eleven years. If there was, Hamas would likely win. The current leaders of the Palestinians carry on the tradition of Arafat, the first Palestinian leader, and embezzle billions of dollars. Ramallah, where the Palestinian leaders live, has some really nice Villas although the really great ones are in Switzerland.

    How the USA screwed up and continues to screw up
    By invading Iraq, the USA changed the balance of power in the middle east and, in particular, strengthen the role of Iran.
    US policy in the area has been a disaster from Iraq, Syria, Libya, Egypt and Yemen.
    There is no longer a functioning government in Syria. Israeli border with Syria is about 90 minutes from Tel Aviv. I have stood at the border several times and watch the war going on in Syria. I could hear the bombs and see the smoke. It is just about an hour drive to Damascus from there. Iraq is falling apart and can only stand up to ISIS with the support of Iran. Libya and Yemen are failed states. Egypt is back safely in the hands of its army instead of the Muslim Brotherhood that Obama supported.

    Is this the time for a Palestinian State
    I would love to see the Palestinian people have their own state. Really! I do have questions about its viability economically unless there was a strong economic cooperation with Israel. For the Palestinians have their own state Israel would have to be secure that such a state will not become a hotbed of terrorism. Just think that Ben Gurion Airport is closer to the West Bank than Oakland is to San Francisco. The distance from the West Bank to Natalya is just nine miles

    If the West Bank was taken over by Hamas or even worse by ISIS, Israel would have to re-occupy it and it would be very ugly and many people, mostly Palestine would be harmed or worse.

    I am not comfortable or proud of how Israel handles the Palestinian situation. I think that many take advantage of the real issues like security to further their own political or economic objectives. But I still think Israel treats the Palestinians better than any Arab country with the possible exception of Jordan. The standard of living in the West Bank is relatively high as is health care and reductions. Women certainly have many more rights than they would experience in most Arab countries. But this does not justify the occupation. The only justification is security and I support that totally but do not want to see that exploited.

    Netanyahu a Politician with a Messiah Complex
    Netanyahu just won reelection. He said some stupid things to get reelected, but he is not the first politician to do that. He said there would not be a two-state solution while he was in power. While that is probably true and something everyone knows, he was supposed to play along with the charade like everyone else. He was also guilty of saying that Arab voters were coming out to the polls in droves because they represent the left. It reminds me of things being done by the Republicans in the USA although they do worse things like passing laws to deny African Americans and Hispanics the right vote.

    I believe that Netanyahu thinks he is the savior of the Jewish people. He is not. In fact, maybe he is the opposite although many would disagree with that. However, I think he is better grounded in the facts of the region than Obama.

    I did not vote for Netanyahu. I am a liberal and have always been. But the constant attack on Israel by liberals in the USA is getting to really upset me. I don’t expect anything from Europe. Europe continues to have anti-Jewish views. This will probably not change in my lifetime.

    Obama such a disappointment
    Obama has really made me angry. The American policies in this region have been terrible. You can’t blame all this on George Bush as much as I would like to. Look at how Obama has handled Iraq, Syria, Libya, Egypt and Yemen. Israel is expected to listen to this man for guidance with respect to Palestine. Now he is working with Iran. This really helps make Israel feel secure about having a Palestinian state as its next door neighbor especially since Iran has been funding Hamas in the south and Hezbollah in the north. I think Obama confuses short term action and agreements with long term results. He really is not very strategic and I don’t think he would have every been hired by me although I did vote for him twice.

    The unholy holy alliance
    Over the years, Israel has been able to get more and more support from the American Right Wing and in particular from the Religious Right. They have some kind of idea that the Jews have to go back to Israel so that the Rapture can take place and somehow all the born again will be called up to Heaven. Strangely, most Jews in the USA (Sheldon Adelson excluded) are either Democrats or Independents and certainly few expect they will be whisked up to Heaven.

    The left wing in the USA has been slowly or turning against Israel and equating the actions of Israel with respect to Palestine as some kind of Apartheid. This is simple-minded, to say the least. I am sure the same people support the election that resulted in Hamas taking over Gaza. These people would not last a day in Gaza before they would be thrown off a roof or hung. Hamas is not yet into cutting off people heads, but it will probably not be long.

    Israeli politics is screwed up by the same movement to the Religious Right. Sometimes I think that the proof that there is no God can be seen by looking at those that say know his wishes.

    So what to do
    First, it is important to become realistic about the situation in this part of the world. It is a really bad neighbor with infected by various gangs. If you lived in such a neighborhood and had children, you might want to build a fence.

    So what is there to do? Let’s stop talking about the mystical two-state solution. Instead, let us spend the next five to ten years to make the West Bank a success by having the equivalent of a Marshall Program to create an industrial revolution in Palestine. Then let us talk again. I am personally willing to commit time and even money to strengthening Palestine but I have trouble finding partners on the other side and I have tried.

  • Bibi, King Maker, Double Agent, Politician, Fool or some combination?

    I am afraid that I have to add my voice to the discussion about the speech or should I say, performance of Bibi Netanyahu at the Congress. There was so much discussion leading up to this event about the purpose that the various parties had in creating this situation. I am not going to repeat all of that, but I will assume you hear a great deal about it.

    Personally I had a lot of difficulties trying to figure out what was going on. Bibi said that he was giving his speech to have an impact on the negotiations with Iran, but it was hard to see how this would have an impact. The negotiations are being lead on the American side by the very people, he pissed off by accepting the invitation to address a joint session of Congress from the Well of the House which was extended by John Boehner, the Speaker of the House. If Bibi wanted to influence Congress he could have spoken to them privately. If he wanted to influence the American People (like their opinion matters), he could have found a different venue for a major speech and then followed up with interviews on the various Cable Networks.

    He said he had to make his speech before a deal was done, but that does not make a lot of sense. Congress will have no role prior to the deal being signed by the Administration. To have a role, they would have to pass legislation which they appear to be very bad at. They would need 60 votes in the Senate and then face a veto by Obama so they would actually need 66 votes in the Senate which is something I don’t think could easily happen. It would have been much better if Bibi spoke to Congress after a deal was signed and asked them to find some way to block it assuming it was really the bad deal he projects.

    That leaves the possibility that he did this for political purposes given that the Israeli election is just two weeks away. This is certainly possible and I can imagine this influenced the timetable. But I find it hard to believe that Bibi used a silver bullet for this purpose. But I am not really sure.

    So what could be the other reasons? I imaged a behind the scenes deal between Netanyahu and the Republicans. The Republicans asked Netanyahu to speak and said that they would make every effort to block the Obama’s deal if he did. But that still does not make sense to me for the reasons I already mentioned with respect to passing veto proof legislation.

    So then I realized what happened. The deal is actually between Obama, Republican, Iran and Israel. The leaks about some of the aspects of the deal, like it being limited to just ten years, are being done on purpose. That way, the real deal will be seen as much better than what was imagined and perhaps seen as good deal. And who can bless such a deal? You got it, Bibi. Bibi will look strong. Boehner and the Republicans will look strong for inviting Bibi and Obama will look, well, stronger in that he got a deal done with Iran. Bibi will say he can go along with the agreement. The Republicans will go along with the agreement claiming that their action in inviting Bibi is responsible for the improvements. The Iranians will also feel good realizing the Americans are not so much different than they are (duplicitous).

  • We must eradicate ISIS

    I was listening to On Point, or better said its podcast, about Sexual Violence under ISIS, and all of a sudden I realized this was not about politics. This was not about war. No, this was about evil.

    I have been following a lot of discussion amongst my friends and in the media about the wisdom of going after ISIS. After all, we have been in a war in the Middle East since 9/11 and many times before. The actions of George Bush in going into Iraq will have to go down in history as one of the greatest blunders of all time. As I supporter of Barak Obama (now I would have to say a feeble supporter), I was all for getting the hell out of Iraq and Afghanistan. Naturally, this would lead to the feeling expressed by many of my left leaning friends, that the ISIS situation is not something that America should have to deal with. It is a problem for the middle eastern countries. Others will say that if we do not fight ISIS now, they will just get stronger and someday attack us at home. So all the discussion is about what is best for us here in the USA.

    But after hearing in detail about how ISIS treats women that turned my stomach and made me sick. After hearing about the genocide practiced against Christians; after hearing about the mass execution of men, I could only think of one thing, the evil of the Nazis and Hitler.

    During the development of the Nazi movement in Europe, the USA was in an isolationist mode. They were dealing with the great depression. The problems of Europe seems far away. And even though the USA government knew of what was happening to the Jews of Europe, they turned a blind eye to that. I can never forgive America for doing that.

    There is something more important than just self-defense. There is something that makes us humans more than just animals. That is understanding that every human life has value and that every woman is a human being and not some object to provide gratification to men. The women that are being raped are mothers, sisters, daughters.

    Why is accepting what is happening in Syria and Iraq any different from ignoring what the Nazi’s did. Do we only have to think about our selfish, self-centered world and ignore the pain of others. Can’t we understand that evil exists and must be eradicated.

    Would we not be proud of our soldiers, if they did put their feet on the ground to save the lives of the innocents. What ISIS is doing is not war no matter how ugly war is. No, ISIS is a rapist that is raping children as young as nine years old. ISIS is evil and must be eradicated.

  • The Syrian Strategy: How the USA, Russia and Israel collaborated to keep Assad in power

    More than a year ago, Israeli diplomats engaged the Americans in a discussion about the situation in Syria. Obama had already issued his “red line” warning about the use of chemical warfare by the Assad regime. Then Assad when ahead and gassed his own people in the tradition of his neighbor, Iraq. Obama was not only concerned about this act but also concerned that these weapons could end up in the hands of Islamic Terrorist and be used against American targets and allies. Russia, on the other hand, wanted to keep Assad in power as he was one of the few world leaders over which Russia still had influence. Israel, who knew more about what was going on in Syria than any other country including Syria, did not want to see Assad go. He was the devil they knew.

    Israel was very concerned that if Assad were overthrown, Syria would be ruled by one or more groups of Islamic Terrorists including ISIS and Hezbollah. Israel shares a border with Syria. Furthermore, the whole mess could extend into Lebanon, which would result in chaos along the entire northern border of Israel. This mess would then extend into Jordan. At this time, Egypt was still being ruled by the Muslim Brotherhood, which as very close to Hamas in Gaza. Not only does Israel have a border with Gaza, but it shares a long border with Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula which was already home to small groups of Muslim Terrorists. And then, of course, there was the West Bank to consider.

    So Israel said to America “You are nuts to push out Assad. It would be even stupider than when you forced us to let the Palestinians have elections, and they elected Hamas. How do you think that worked out? Why not make a deal with Assad and the Russian? Get rid of the chemical weapons for a guarantee that you will take no military action against him. Get the Russian to help you with this. If ISIS and the other’s get control of Syria, you will wish that you had not killed Bin Laden.”

    Then another potential benefit of this strategy became apparent. Since the USA would not overtly help Assad stay in power, the terrorists would still control some significant territory. And what would they do? They would expand into Iraq. The Americans had lost influence in Iraq after wasting so much money and blood. Iraq was controlled by the Shiites that was to say that it was becoming a satellite state of Iran. The Americans had no ability to effect this. But ISIS could. The only people ISIS hated more than the long list of people they hated, including Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus and Atheists, was the Shiites. They would form an alliance with the disenfranchised Sunni minority in Iraq. The only way for the Shiites to survive would form a more inclusive government which included the Sunnis, which meant moving away from the orbit of Iran.

    The ISIS strategy proved to be inspired. These people could not have played their designated role better even if they had come from Central Casting. Eventually, the Americans and maybe some European Allies will take care of ISIS through a combination of military action and payoffs. They will be able to attack ISIS in Syria, which will further strengthen Assad, bring stability back to Syria. Assad can keep his army engaged by killing Sunni’s. Israeli tourist can relax and visit the Golan Heights where they could watch the fighting below while having a picnic. The USA will end up having influence again in Iraq which they can use in their war of words with Iran. Russia can keep one of the few leaders that like Putin. And while this strategy plays out over the next few years, Russia can slowly take over the Ukraine.