Two Thirds Done

Thoughts and experiences of an eighty one year old Wild Duck.

Avram Miller by the sea
EN | IT

587 posts since 2006

Category: Palestine

  • People Need Something to Lose

    Side view of a single-story building with a stone pathway, surrounded by greenery and trees.

    My garden was built by workers from Gaza in 1975

    A friend of my wife, a well-known television producer, is visiting Israel. During one of his meetings, he learned that on October 7 thousands of Gazans who were not Hamas fighters followed Hamas into Israel and took part in the atrocities. He was astonished.

    The Israeli army later estimated that about 6,000 Gazans crossed the border that day. About 3,800 were Hamas’s elite fighters. The other 2,200 or so were a mix of members of other armed groups and ordinary civilians. It is the civilians I want to talk about. Frankly, I was not surprised when I learned about this a few days after October 7. The civilians of Gaza had been living in what was called by some the “world’s largest open-air prison.” A prison, I have to add, that was run by a gang of inmates, Hamas. I was not surprised; this was the first time they could leave, and the opportunity to take “treasures” like automobiles, TVs and computers must have been so tempting. However, I was shocked to learn about the violence some of them committed against Israelis they found, including murder and rape. I do not want to conclude that these civilians were typical of the people living in Gaza. I do not know. I do know that since the 1990s, they have been systematically taught to hate Israelis.

    The Gaza I first knew

    I found myself thinking not only about October 7, but about the Gaza I first knew more than fifty years ago. I moved to Israel in 1974. Gaza and the West Bank were under Israeli military occupation, but the physical separation that exists today did not exist in anything like its present form. I lived close to the West Bank, and I regularly drove there to buy vegetables. I didn’t often go to Gaza as it was about forty miles away but I employed workers from Gaza to help me build my garden. This sounds almost unimaginable today.

    I don’t mean to romanticize the occupation at that time. Palestinians and Israelis certainly had grievances against one another then. But the relationship was different. There was human contact. The populations were intertwined economically and physically in ways that have largely disappeared.

    Oslo and the two intifadas

    This started to change with the first intifada, which began in 1987. Then came the Oslo peace agreement in 1993, and on July 1, 1994, Yasser Arafat returned, first to Gaza and a few days later to Jericho in the West Bank. I believe Israel, under a left-wing government at the time, was serious about a two-state solution, but Arafat was not. I also believe that Arafat stole billions from his own people, and his successor, Abbas, has faced persistent allegations of corruption, but that is another story.

    Over the next fifty years, Israel built walls, some physical, some political and some psychological. The government also kept expanding the Jewish settlements on Palestinian land in both the West Bank and Gaza, which had begun after the 1967 war, under the mistaken belief this would make Israel safer.

    How did we get from there to here?

    One of the decisive moments came in 2005.

    Prime Minister Ariel Sharon made the extraordinary decision to remove every Israeli settlement from Gaza and withdraw Israeli forces from inside that territory. Roughly 8,000 Israeli settlers were evacuated, some forcibly by Israeli soldiers and police.

    I remember how traumatic this was within Israel. Israelis watched Israeli soldiers carrying other Israelis from their homes.

    Whatever one thinks about Sharon’s decision, it created an extraordinary moment. For the first time since 1967, there were no permanent Israeli settlements or military bases inside Gaza. But there was opportunity.

    Hamas takes over

    What happened next was not what many people hoped for. In January 2006, Hamas defeated Fatah in Palestinian legislative elections. The struggle between the two movements eventually became violent, and in June 2007 Hamas seized control of Gaza. Fatah and the Palestinian Authority remained dominant in the West Bank. Gaza and the West Bank effectively became two different Palestinian political entities.

    The open-air prison

    Rocket attacks against Israel continued. Israel progressively tightened restrictions around Gaza, particularly after the Hamas takeover, while Egypt also severely restricted movement across its border.

    Gaza became increasingly isolated, “the world’s largest open-air prison.” One run by its imates.

    Israel controlled most access by land as well as Gaza’s airspace and maritime access. Egypt controlled the other land frontier. There was no functioning airport. Movement of people and goods became highly restricted, although Gazans could sometimes obtain permits to enter Israel for work, medical treatment and other purposes.

    There was an undeniable reality behind that phrase: roughly two million people were living in a very small territory from which leaving was extraordinarily difficult. It was a prison of geography, politics, security and history. And Hamas ruled inside it.

    A generation grew up behind the fence

    This is the part of the story that worries me most. Half the population of Gaza is under 18. They grew up without any knowledge of the world I had known in the 1970s, a world where someone from Gaza could work in my garden. Rather, they knew checkpoints, permits, rockets, Israeli air strikes, Hamas, periodic wars and a border fence separating them from a country they were taught to regard as their enemy.

    At the same time, Israelis living near Gaza grew up with rocket shelters, warning sirens and the knowledge that an organization committed to armed struggle against Israel governed just a few kilometers away.

    Each side accumulated its own memories. Each generation inherited the fears of the generation before it.

    Then came October 7, 2023.

    Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups broke through the Israeli defenses and attacked communities, military positions and a music festival. About 1,200 people were killed and roughly 250 were taken hostage.

    For Israelis, October 7 changed something fundamental. The border fence had represented security. Suddenly it represented the failure of security. And whatever sympathy many Israelis had once felt for the civilians living on the other side of that fence became much harder to sustain.

    The war that followed

    The war that then resulted brought death and destruction on an enormous scale to Palestinians. I do not support the actions Israel took and is taking after October 7 in Gaza. I think Israel should have first asked other countries to help it get its hostages back and to participate in disarming Hamas. Instead it acted out of rage. The rage is understandable, but the results were not good. I will not speak here of the ignorance of so many that only see Israel’s actions and do not assign any responsibility to Hamas and its supporters like Iran. Where does this end?

    Netanyahu’s responsibility

    The government of Netanyahu carries a heavy share of the responsibility for the situation. He has been in power about two-thirds of the time since 1996. He did not just ignore Gaza. For years he allowed Qatar to send money to Hamas there, because a divided Palestinian leadership suited him. What did he think would happen? Israel needed to work with other countries to find a solution for the people that lived there, not just build a bigger fence. The people of Gaza, like all people, deserved a decent life for themselves and their children. When you have nothing to lose, you will risk everything.

    My dream for Gaza

    I had, and still have, a dream for Gaza. Imagine, for a moment, something radically different.

    It starts with both Israel and Egypt offering land to create a “Gaza II” adjacent to the current one, “Gaza I.” Then imagine a massive regional development project involving Israel, Egypt, Palestinians and outside countries willing to finance it. New Palestinian communities would be built with modern infrastructure.

    Desalination plants could produce water, as they already do on a massive scale in Israel. Solar installations could produce abundant electricity. Modern agriculture could use some of that water and energy. New cities could be designed rather than improvised. Industry could provide jobs. A functioning port could connect the population with the outside world.

    Most importantly, imagine hundreds of thousands of young Palestinians waking up in the morning with someplace to go. A job, a business, a university, farms, and industry. A future!

    Can prosperity become part of security?

    We have spent decades trying walls, checkpoints, military deterrence, blockades, rockets and wars. They have not produced peace. We need a different way forward.

    The West Bank is equally difficult but needs a different solution

    I understand why many Israelis fear the creation of a Palestinian state immediately adjacent to Israel’s principal population centers. Israel is extremely narrow in places, and October 7 made territorial security concerns much more visceral.

    Palestinians, however, cannot reasonably be expected to live indefinitely without political rights, economic opportunity and control over their own future.

    At the same time, there are Israelis who regard the West Bank, Judea and Samaria as an inseparable part of the historical Land of Israel and support permanent Israeli control or annexation.

    These positions do not fit neatly together but that is the reality.

    I can imagine arrangements that might eventually reconcile Palestinian self-government with Israeli security. I have much more difficulty imagining the political leadership capable of implementing them today. And perhaps that is what saddens me most.

    A word about the hatred directed at Israel and at Jews in general

    My heart breaks to see how Israel and Jews in general are being treated. I have no problem with people being critical of the Israeli government. I am myself. But unless you think that every American is responsible for Donald Trump, you cannot think that every Israeli is responsible for Netanyahu, let alone non-Israeli Jews. How people can support Hamas is beyond me. I do not understand the stupidity of gay people that support the people that would kill them after cutting off their testicles. Women that support rapists who would cut off their breasts.

    The supporters of the Palestinians have accomplished nothing for the Palestinian people. They are not really for Palestinians because they know nothing about them. They are just against Israel and Jews. The result of their actions has only strengthened Israel’s resolve and feeling of isolation, which can lead to the government taking more actions against the Palestinians.

    I remember something different

    I keep returning to those men from Gaza who helped me build my garden in 1974.

    I don’t remember discussing geopolitics with them.

    They came to work and I paid them.

    We worked together, we smiled. My wife would bring them water. My children would play with them

    Then they went home to their wives and children

    It was hardly a solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But it was human contact, and human contact matters. Today a young Israeli and a young Gazan can live perhaps twenty kilometers apart and inhabit completely different universes. Each may know the other primarily as someone dangerous.

    Something to lose

    I don’t pretend to know how to solve it.

    I do believe, however, that security alone cannot be the objective. Nor can Palestinian nationalism, Israeli nationalism, revenge, historical entitlement or military victory by themselves produce a livable future.

    People need something to lose and something to love.

    They need homes, jobs, education, businesses and families whose futures seem more valuable than the promises offered by extremists.

    Maybe that sounds naïve after October 7 and the war that followed. Perhaps it is.

    But after watching this conflict for more than fifty years, I find the alternative much harder to believe: that another wall, another generation of hatred and another war will somehow produce a different result.

  • Israel’s actions and its impact on the Jewish Diaspora

    Most Israeli Jews think of themselves first as Israelis and second as Jews. Regarding the Jewish diaspora, they generally believe that one of Israel’s core purposes, the Zionist mission, is to provide a safe haven for Jews. While I disagree with the actions of the current Israeli government, I subscribe to this belief myself. I am a Zionist and believe that the Jewish people must have their own homeland if they are to survive.

    Unfortunately, this movement has been distorted under Netanyahu and his coalition, particularly through the support of the settler movement and the treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank. While I understand the desire for an Israel that encompasses the heart of the ancient Jewish homeland in Judea and Samaria, we must also recognize that Palestinians have a legitimate claim. Regrettably, they do not reciprocate by accepting the right of Jews to their own homeland.

    As I have written previously, I believe the future of the diaspora is already in jeopardy due to intermarriage and declining birthrates. While Israel’s actions since October 7, 2023, have contributed significantly to the rapid rise of antisemitism, they did not cause it; they merely gave expression to the latent antisemitism that characterizes much of the Western world.

    (more…)
  • I Will Not Allow Antisemitism to Steal My Humanity

    The months since October 7, 2023 have changed something in the world as well as something in me.

    The barbaric attack by Hamas on Israeli civilians shook Israel to its core. Families murdered. Women assaulted. Hundreds taken hostage. I spoke almost daily with friends in Israel. The grief in their voices was raw. The fear was real. The anger was overwhelming. I felt it too.

    What followed was a war that has devastated Gaza. Entire neighborhoods destroyed. Tens of thousands killed. Images of injured and displaced children broadcast across the world. As the war unfolded, something else happened. The world polarized.

    Israel was condemned in capitals and on campuses. Protesters filled streets in Europe and America. In some places, criticism of policy blurred into something darker  hostility toward Jews as Jews. Antisemitism reared its ugly head once again. Jewish communities far from the battlefield were treated as extensions of a government they did not elect and may not support. I found myself reacting defensively.

    When people accused Israel of genocide, I rejected the claim. Words matter. Genocide has a definition. I do not believe this war, however tragic, meets it.

    Some spoke as if October 7 had not happened. In some cases, that it was even justified. Hamas targeted civilians deliberately and in the most despicable ways. It knew Israel would respond militarily. It knew civilians in Gaza would suffer. It prepared for both the military confrontation and the public relations battle. Israel was prepared for one of those and not the other. I disagreed with aspects of how the Israeli government handled the war. But I understood the trauma that shaped its response.

    Then somewhere in the outrage, the arguments, and the rising antisemitism, something shifted inside me. I stopped being empathetic.

    (more…)
  • If you want to help Palestine, do something that matters.

    I guess I need to start by saying that while I am a supporter of Israel, I am not a supporter of its current government and in particular how it has conducted itself in Gaza. 

    I must also say that Hamas and its supporters are aberrant.  They are both religious fanatics but also scum.  How women and gay people can support them is not comprehensible.  Hamas are killers of babies, rapists and torturers of their captives. They have given ups any right to be alive.

    All around the world there are millions of people coming out in support of Palestinians and in particular the people of Gaza while ignoring the plights of so many others

    • Russian invasion of Ukraine
    • Sudanese civil war (2023–present)  
    • Conflict in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo / DRC–Rwanda tensions  
    • Myanmar internal conflict / civil war
    • Uyghurs 

    Just to name a few.  

    (more…)
  • Israel and Palestine: A Personal Proposal

    I’ve lived in Israel twice in my life—first in the seventies, then again from 2015 to 2023. Back in the seventies, I lived just a few miles from the West Bank. I could cross over freely. The men who built our garden came from Gaza. Life felt complicated, yes, but also connected.

    In my most recent years in Israel, I again traveled into the West Bank. I met Palestinians, supported nonprofits, and even helped some young people with their education. They were warm, kind, and eager for a better future.

    That’s why October 7th shook me so deeply. I don’t support Netanyahu’s policies or Israel’s heavy hand in Gaza. But that doesn’t mean I can accept what Hamas did. I understand the rage Israelis feel. What I don’t understand is the world’s double standard—the marches that cry for Palestinian rights but fail to condemn Hamas or call for the release of hostages. That silence speaks volumes.

    I sometimes joke that I support a “two-state solution”: one where Palestinians and Jews live side by side, and another where their politicians are kept far away from them. Beneath the joke is a serious truth: the people can live together, but the politics keep them apart.

    (more…)
  • Israel and the Future of the Jewish People Part II

    The history of the Jewish people before the establishment of the Kingdom of Israel around 1000 BCE, under King David, is not fully understood. What we do know is that the ancestors of the Jewish nation lived in Canaan. The Kingdom of Israel was their first independent state.

    Over time, the land was conquered repeatedly—first by the Assyrian Empire, then by the Babylonians, later by the Persians, and eventually by the Greeks. Independence was briefly restored under the Hasmoneans, but Rome ultimately took control. Following a series of revolts, the Romans forced many Jews into exile, scattering them throughout their empire, particularly in North Africa and Europe. Yet not all left—Jews continued to live in the Land of Israel, maintaining an unbroken presence that has lasted to this day.

    (more…)
  • Israel and the Future of the Jewish People: Part I

    I am deeply saddened and concerned about what has been happening in Israel, especially since October 7, 2023. But it did not begin that day. For years, Israel has been shifting steadily to the right, particularly under the leadership of Benjamin Netanyahu. Ironically, had Arab citizens of Israel voted at the same rate as Jewish citizens, Netanyahu’s coalition would not have secured a majority.

    It is often said that Netanyahu clings to power to avoid the consequences of his bribery trial. While there is truth to that, I believe the greater reality is simpler: he wants to stay in power for the sake of power itself. He has become a megalomaniac, much like Donald Trump, convinced that “he alone” can save his country. Meanwhile, the opposition in Israel has grown weaker and less clear in its leadership. Tragically, the same phenomenon can be seen in the United States. As a citizen of both countries, I find myself living under the leadership of two men I deeply despise.

    (more…)
  • Israel and the Shattered Mirror

    I try to write about Israel and, in particular, the war, which began on Oct. 7th, but I become overwhelmed with emotion and confusion. I feel like I am looking at my image in a shattered mirror. I can recognize myself in the fragments, but parts of my face are missing or distorted. There is no way for me to repair a shattered mirror. 

    Israel lives in my heart. It is the only country in the world I have ever loved. Zionism has been an integral part of my life since I was a small child growing up in the fog of San Francisco. 

    The State of Israel and I are almost the same age. I was born on January 27, 1945, the day Auschwitz was liberated. David Ben-Gurion, Israel’s first Prime Minister, declared the State of Israel just three years and four months later.  This declaration resulted in the War of Independence when the armies of the neighboring Arab countries attacked the newly formed Jewish State, Israel. The Jews accepted the decision of the United Nations to establish two nations where there had been none for more than 2000 years: a state primarily for Jews and another primarily for Arabs. This is now called the “Two State Solution.” The Arabs did not accept the UN resolution.  What they wanted is what they still shout for, a Palestinian state from The River to the Sea, meaning from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea. A land without Jews.

    Please keep in mind that Israel is a tiny country, just the size of New Jersey. Arab countries represented about 10% of the world’s land mass and were much larger than the United States  or Europe. Israel is about 0.2% the size of the Arab countries. 

    Israel was established only three years after a third of all Jews were murdered by the Nazis in the holocaust. The goal of the Nazis was to rid Europe of its Jews, who numbered close to ten million in 1938 and represented about 2% of the total European population.  Now, there are just a bit more than a million Jews in Europe, representing less than 0.2% of its population.  This number is expected to decline. Hitler may have lost the war, but he achieved his goal of eradicating the Jews from Europe. 

    Since 1948, Israel has fought many wars. There has been almost one major war every ten years, plus constant Palestinian terrorism. Against this backdrop, Israel became stronger and stronger both economically and militarily. It has one of the world’s most vibrant and successful high-tech industries.  Its GDP per capita is higher than the EU’s. 

    Even with the continuous threats from hostile Arab countries and, eventually, Iran, many Jews finally felt safe. The stronger its military became, the safer it felt. But to feel secure, Israel had to ignore the plight of their Palestinian neighbors.  Rather than genocide, Israel created a situation where the Palestinian population grew very fast. 1948, there were less than 600,000 Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.  Now, they number more than 5 million, and this does not count the Arabs living in Israel proper.  

    Palestinians suffered greatly from the war of 1948. Many were forced out of their homes by the Israelis, while others fled at the direction of their leaders. The War of Independence ended with an armistice and a temporary border, the “Green Line.” 

     It is hard to know how things would have turned out had they not attacked Israel but rather established their state as per the UN mandate.  Certainly it would have been a lot better. Instead, they became refugees in Arab lands that would not offer them citizenship. The Palestinians that remained in Israel faired much better. The Arab countries never really cared about Palestinians and still do not. But they could not accept a non-Muslim nation.  There has never been a Palestinian nation. The last independent nation existed more than 2000 years earlier, and it was Jewish.   The area that is now Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza was called Palestine by the British, who took it over after WWI from the Turks in 1929. The Turks had ruled this area for almost 500 years. The Jews that lived there were called Palestinians.  

    The Arab people that lived in the region were mainly tribal. After 1948, there was no attempt to create a Palestinian nation. Jordan took the West Bank, and Egypt took Gaza. The Jordanians integrated the West Bank Population, giving them citizenship and full rights.  Yasser Arafat formed the Palestinian Liberation Organization in 1964 while living in Jordan. However, later,  the Palestinian leader was thrown out when he tried to overthrow the Jordanian monarchy in 1970.   The Egyptians never gave rights to those living in Gaza. 

    In 1967, the six-day war resulted in the Palestinians living in the West and in Gaza coming under the control of Israel. Initially, there was no border between Israel proper and the West Bank.  I can remember traveling there. It was just 15 minutes from where I lived. We would do grocery shopping. We felt safe. 

    Gaza was under Egyptian control.  After the six-day war, these areas were referred to as the Palestinian territories. The long-term occupation of these areas was a great strategic error on the part of Israel, in my opinion.  Israel mistakenly believed that they could trade the West Bank and perhaps Gaza for peace treaties with the Jordanians and the Egyptians. But frankly, both countries were glad to be rid of the people living there.

    There were many in Israel who thought the West Bank should be part of Israel as it was in biblical days. This resulted in the settler movement, which has been a cancer in the body of Israel and under the Netanyahu government, metastasized. The rise of Palestinian nationalism under Arafat had a major effect on Israel’s willingness to see a Palestinian nation be established just 20 miles from Tel Aviv. In 2005, Israel left Gaza only to see it taken over by the terrorist organization Hamas. Now, after October 7th, I see no way that Israel would agree to a Palestinian state. But without a Palestinian state, there can never be peace.

    I first moved to Israel in 1974 with my wife and two sons. My daughter would be born there.  We left in 1979 for the USA.  I could not adjust to living in Israel, nor could my wife. It was one of the most significant failures of my life. 

    In 2015, I returned to live there once again but in a very different Israel.  It was a joy for me to live in that Israel. I felt at home, even though I struggled with Hebrew. I felt I belonged in a way I had never felt elsewhere. But the country was turning more and more to the right politically.   In the summer of 2023, I realized that Netanyahu, the Prime Minister, was, for his own purposes, dividing the country and moving more and more to embrace right-wing extremists in order to stay in power.  We had decided to leave the country in 2025 but are plans were accelerated. We were out of Israel on Oct. 7th and chose not to return. That was more than ten months ago.  We put our beautiful home on the market and recently sold it. 

    Less than a third of Israelis are descendants of holocaust survivors. About 60% of Israelis trace their lineage to Arab-speaking countries, as about 800,000 Jews were forced out of those countries after the War of Independence.  Most Israelis are secular, but there is a large group of ultra-orthodox. Since the creation of the state of Israel, the Jews living there moved from being Jews living in Israel to becoming Israeli Jews.  Their identity is primarily with Israel. Israel has compulsory military service for both men and women. The exemption from this is the almost 20% of Arabs living in Israel and the ultra-orthodox, although the latter is in contention.  It was the Israeli Defense Forces that created the melting pot that became Israel. Rich or poor, male or female, black or white, served together.  

    Even as a Zionist who believes in the right of Jews to have a homeland,  I was torn by Israel’s actions concerning the Palestinians. I despise the Settler Movement. I was appalled by the treatment of the Palestinians in the West Bank and the actions that Israel took in Gaza. Still, I also realized the role the Palestinians and, in particular, their corrupt leaders play.  I took some direct action to help Palestinians with little or no impact.  It was clear to me that Abbas and his cronies did not want to solve the problems.  They are corrupt and have benefited from the situation.  

    I am proud of Israel’s contributions to the world. I loved living in Tel Aviv. But I also saw Israel moving more and more to the right.  One of my main motivations for leaving the USA in 2015 was Trump.  I did not want to live in a country where almost half the people had voted for this dreadful man. But Israel had its version, Benjamin Netanyahu. When he was elected last time, I sadly realized that we could not stay in Israel. So, we made a plan to leave in 2025.  No many has done more to harm the Jewish people since WWII  than Netanyahu. 

    On October 3, 2023, we went to Bodrum, Turkey, to celebrate my wife, Deborah’s birthday. I woke up on October 7 to the news from Israel. I, like so many, was stunned and in pain. It was hard to understand how something like this could happen.  I thought that Israel could protect itself from a direct attack by terrorists. 

    We had planned to travel in Europe until 19 October, when we were to fly back to Israel. However, we decided not to return and have not been back since. The Israel that we left on Oct. 3rd no longer exists. I am trying to see how it could return. It is possible, just not probable. 

    Of course, I have mixed feelings about not returning. Sometimes, I feel guilty, although I do not think there would be much I could do if I were there.

    I have been watching what has happened and have concluded that Israel has been broken and not broken by its disgusting enemies but by itself and its failed leadership. Netanyahu has broken the country. He has shattered the reflection that was the soul of the Jewish people. No one has done more harm to the Jewish people since Hitler. 

    In the meantime, the war continues in Gaza. Is it just? I have a hard time deciding the answer to this question. I believe that the Israeli government failed its people by not protecting them from Hamas and then took actions that only resulted in destroying Israel’s standing in the world and did not make Israel safer.  So many of the hostages were killed.  I can think of a number of better strategies than going into Gaza.  Now it is time to get out.  Nothing is being accomplished.  Israel should agree to leave in return for all the hostages.  Then Israel should build a real security border.  It should also make it clear that any rockets being sent into Israel from Gaza will result in major bombings in Gaza.  They should invite the United States to put together a group of nations to rebuild Gaza.   

    How many innocent people can be killed in justification for killing evil people? I don’t have an answer to that. I think of the Israeli soldiers who have lost their lives, and I think of the Israeli soldiers who now have blood on their hands.  How will they recover? How will the people of Gaza ever recover from the actions of Hamas and their horrible leadership? 

  • The war between Israel and Iran has started, and Israel is loosing

    The war between Israel and Iran has started, and Israel is loosing

    I don’t know this, but I believe that Iran orchestrated the war between Hamas and Israel that started on Oct. 7th. I don’t think that the leaders of Hamas were capable of planning what happened.

    Someone laid a trap that Israel fell into. It was planned over years. The idea was to do exactly what happened on Oct. 7th. Someone realized that the young Hamas fighters (really terrorists is a better word) could be unleashed to do the most horrendous things; cutting babies out of wombs, gang raping women until the pelvis broke, raping dead women and even children, cutting off the limbs of children in front of their parents, and mutilating dead bodies. The list goes on and on. They realized that the hopeless and indoctrinated youth of Gaza longed for martyrdom as the only way to get out of the hell hole that was Gaza.

    They knew that Israel, confronted with the horrors of Oct. 7th, would have to bomb and then invade Gaza. They knew that even though Israel would not target civilians, there was no way that civilians would not be killed or injured. That did not matter to those responsible for Oct. 7th, including the Iranian leadership. Their mission was to turn the world against Israel. And they succeeded. They feared that Israel was becoming more and more powerful and would soon see a significant expansion of its relationship with other Arab countries, especially Saudi Arabia.

    Israel is seen in Iran as the little Satan, while its big brother, the USA, is the big Satan. A stronger Israel meant a more substantial American presence in the Middle East.

    The intellectually bankrupt government of Israel led by Nethanyhu was focused on dividing the country with its judicial reforms that would have, for all intent and purpose, ended democracy. Netanyahu could only stay in power by catering to the most extreme aspects of Israeli politics. He unleashed the settlers who longed for a Greater Israel (Israel from the sea to the river). But Netanyahu had only won by 30,000 votes. And once in power, he lost some of the support of rational, although right-wing voters. He presided over the weakest government in the history of Israel. One that is weaker and weaker every day and is not capable of dealing with the current situation.

    Hatred for Israel’s treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza had been growing for years. While I understand the responsibility for the Palestinian situation has to be laid on both sides, with the Palestinian Authority being inept, corrupt, and pretty much on the payroll of the Israeli government and with Hamas, a brutal, medieval authoritarian government committed to the distortion of Israel. But much of the responsibility belongs to the Israeli people who accepted the situation, kicking the can down the street for decades. And much of the responsibility belongs to the UN, a useless organization, that created a culture of refugees.

    In my opinion, Israel should have waited before attacking Gaza. They should have sealed off Gaza. They should have offered a prisoner exchange. They should have called on the other nations to work with them to remove Hamas. Failing that, they should have worked on a plan to evacuate Gaza and flooded the tunnels with water or poisoned air.

    Now, the world has turned against Israel. Antisemitism abounds. Israel has been seriously weakened. Its economy is suffering significantly. Its reputation as a power has been diminished. The good news is the people, not the government, are united. At some point, can’t be soon enough, Nethanyhu and his band of incompetent ministers will be thrown out. Hopefully, there will be new leadership, maybe from the movement developed to stop the judicial overhaul. But I don’t see how Israel can easily recover.

    What does that mean for the rest of the world? The bad guys appear to be winning. Russia and Iran show the power that comes if you don’t give a shit what people think about you and you don’t give a shit about the lives of your people.

    Iran will not stop with Israel. I think Biden knows this.

  • New Gaza-A long term solution

      The situation in Gaza is dire. While I think Hamas is an organization of monsters who, after the events of October 7th, have forfeited their rights to be treated as human beings, I do not feel that way about the people of Gaza in general. I take no joy in their suffering. It is just the opposite.  

    Gaza has been described as the world’s largest open-air prison. I would add, run a group of violent inmates who care nothing for the other prisoners.  

    Like many, I am in despair watching the reporting from Gaza about the killing of innocent people. But I don’t know what should be done in the short term. So, forgive me for not dealing with that in this blog post. This blog post is focused on what can be done in the long term to provide the people of Gaza a peaceful and prosperous life while providing the people of Israel with the same.

    In 1948, before the War of Independence, which Palestinians also call the Nakba. Gaza was a fishing village of 80,000 people. After the war, 120,000 fled from what is now Israel to Gaza, bringing the total to 200,000 inhabitants. Now, the population is 2.2 million, with half being children.  

    Gaza is one of the most densely populated areas in the world. Next to it is the Negev region of Israel, which represents 55% of the total land of Israel. It is primarily a desert with a very low population. It is 30 times the size of Gaza. My proposal (which I have made in the past) is to expand the size of Gaza. I would like to see that happen by both Egypt and Israel given equal amounts of land. After all, the Sinai is 165 times the size of Gaza and has almost no people. This idea is not another “Nakba.” This land would belong to the Palestinians.  

    Before you yell at me that Negev and Sinai are deserts, I know that, think about https://www.neom.com/en-us being built in the desert.  

    For now, I will assume that Egypt will give no land. I propose that Israel will an area close to the existing Gaza. In this area, I will call New Gaza and refer to the current Gaza as Old Gaza.  

    A new city would be created. The financing would come from an international consortium including the USA, Saudi Arabia, and the USA. Part of the area would be for farming. I know it is a desert, but Israel grows about 25% of its produce there. Much of the current workforce would be involved in the construction of the city. New Gaza would be a demilitarized Palestine under the control of the Palestinian Authority, but an international group would ensure that it was demilitarized. All people in Gaza that were not part of Hamas would be able to relocate to New Gaza. All remaining members of Hamas would be allowed safe passage to Iran. Once Old Gaza was vacated, it would be leveled. Then it would be turned into a resort area similar to Sharm El Sheik. This would give additional opportunities for those living in Gaza to first work on the construction and then later in the resorts. Additional industries would be established, including a high-tech center. An airport and a maritime port would be built.  

    People in Gaza would have an opportunity to work in Israel proper. Tel Aviv is just 44 miles from Gaza, for instance. A tunnel from Gaza would be built connecting it to the West Bank. 

    This project would take as much as ten years to accomplish, but it could be done in less time. There would be significant progress along the way. The result would be a place for Palestinians to live in safety and dignity and prosper.